Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
22 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The moment you realized you were an Atheist... (Original Post) NeoGreen Sep 2019 OP
Quite thought provoking. dewsgirl Sep 2019 #1
Indeed. calimary Sep 2019 #2
Yeah, it's a process Farmer-Rick Sep 2019 #3
That is so very true Ferrets are Cool Sep 2019 #4
I have found that you cannot convert anyone nor should you try... NeoGreen Sep 2019 #5
You are so right Gelliebeans Sep 2019 #11
Just makes sense dna80 Jan 2020 #22
Yep, you can only turn on the lights. Iggo Nov 2019 #17
Speak for yourself. Aquaria Dec 2019 #18
Will do, and if I may be so bold to ask... NeoGreen Dec 2019 #20
I remember the exact moment. needledriver Sep 2019 #6
Sounds like me. Aquaria Dec 2019 #19
Walking home with my parents after Easter services. yellerpup Sep 2019 #7
For me, that is such a strange perspective Boomer Sep 2019 #8
I agree totally Gelliebeans Sep 2019 #10
That's probably why I don't relate to the Atheist Movement Boomer Sep 2019 #12
Good Point. n/t Gelliebeans Sep 2019 #13
Organizing Atheists, is like herding cats. yortsed snacilbuper Oct 2019 #14
Non religious family but Gelliebeans Sep 2019 #9
The museum in Balboa park? Act_of_Reparation Oct 2019 #16
When I "rebelled" Piasladic Oct 2019 #15
preparation for marriage dna80 Jan 2020 #21

Farmer-Rick

(11,399 posts)
3. Yeah, it's a process
Wed Sep 25, 2019, 07:59 AM
Sep 2019

First I stopped believing the Christmas story. Then I stopped believing how preachers twisted the words of the bible. Then I threw out the bible all together. Then I started questioning the idea of a God.

Then I just gave up rationalizing a bunch of stupid ideas tied up with a bunch of lies and propaganda and picked up the aithiest label.

There is not credible or sufficient evidence that any god exists. In fact this world behaves just as I would expect it to behave if there is No God.

Ferrets are Cool

(21,957 posts)
4. That is so very true
Wed Sep 25, 2019, 08:08 AM
Sep 2019

I can't pinpoint it....I called myself an agnostic for years before I finally admitted to myself that I was an atheist. I am very proud of the fact that I do not believe in the fantasy of an All Knowing Loving Father looking down on mankind, however, I DO NOT go around trying to convert others to my belief.

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts)
5. I have found that you cannot convert anyone nor should you try...
Wed Sep 25, 2019, 08:11 AM
Sep 2019

...the only path to Atheism is self-driven through self-realization.

Our job is to show that we exist, and that it is Ok to be an Atheist.

Gelliebeans

(5,043 posts)
11. You are so right
Fri Sep 27, 2019, 03:48 PM
Sep 2019

Atheism isn’t a set a beliefs it’s just non-belief. It is an epiphany for some and a default for others. A safe place to be with others that have questions or have already come to a conclusion for themselves is good.

dna80

(10 posts)
22. Just makes sense
Wed Jan 22, 2020, 10:11 AM
Jan 2020

I act in an ethical manner because I care about people the earth and myself, not because I am threatened by a god or religion.
What I do in life I take responsibility for not the devil or a god.

Iggo

(48,262 posts)
17. Yep, you can only turn on the lights.
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 07:28 PM
Nov 2019

They still gotta look around for themselves.

When I argue with idiots who like to argue with atheists, it's not to change the idiots' minds. It's so that the spectators might go "Hmm."

I'm just turning on the lights, man.

 

Aquaria

(1,076 posts)
18. Speak for yourself.
Sat Dec 28, 2019, 04:06 AM
Dec 2019

I’ve converted people to atheism.

I didn’t do it by dragging anyone to a science meeting or haranguing them. I just dropped little bombs in their arguments and minds that they couldn’t shake free of.

One guy, it started with him saying he’s Catholic, because if he did things that weren’t so great, he would be forgiven.

I simply asked, “Why do you need a third party involved in something you’re responsible for? If you can, seek forgiveness for a wrong you did with the person you wronged, and if they won’t forgive you then why not forgive yourself?”

So some of it I got from my Jewish heritage, but the rest is simply common sense.

Anyway, the Catholic came back to me a few months later, and said he couldn’t shake what I’d said, he kept going over and over it, and realized it was true: he didn’t need the church for forgiveness. And with that delusion shattered, he was starting to question what he needed them for at all.

With a few more little bombs dropped in a similar vein, he became an atheist in no time at all.

NeoGreen

(4,033 posts)
20. Will do, and if I may be so bold to ask...
Sat Dec 28, 2019, 09:02 AM
Dec 2019

...could you post some of your wisdom 'bombs' around here? They're sorely needed.

 

needledriver

(836 posts)
6. I remember the exact moment.
Wed Sep 25, 2019, 08:33 AM
Sep 2019

I was in 5th grade. I had parents of two religions, so I was raised with Christian and Jewish holidays and traditions - no formal religious training. My parents didn’t push me in any particular direction, but let me make up my own mind. I hadn’t really committed one way or the other on whether there was an omnipotent omniscient bearded dude on a gilded throne with flights of angels hearing every sparrow fall, but one day a girl in class asked me if I believed in God. I said "No." She asked me where I thought the universe came from if god didn’t create it? I asked her "Where did god come from?" and she got a glazed, pious look in her eyes and chanted "He always was and always will be." I thought "This is bullshit." (or the ten year old kid equivalent of this is bullshit).

 

Aquaria

(1,076 posts)
19. Sounds like me.
Sat Dec 28, 2019, 05:02 AM
Dec 2019

My mother is xian, but my Jewish grandmother begged her to have us kids learn Judaism, even after my parents divorced. So I had both, although after I finally went to Temple and Hebrew school, I much preferred it to the xian cult, and became ever more insistent about Judaism being enough religion on my on time, thanks very much. Bad enough I went to a xian school, but to sit through their hate cult meetings was intolerable to me.

Judaism was a big reason why I became atheist. I connected with it and its community better than I ever had the xian cult, but that wasn’t what unsettled me. The shock of realizing not everyone believed the same things had me questioning if either one of them knew what they were talking about.

And then came that day I was doing homework for my parochial school religious class, about the 10 silly rules, and the textbook said that we could have no other deities but HaShem, because HaShem was a jealous god.

For all of my life to that point, every adult had drummed it into our heads that jealousy was a bad thing. And nearly all of them had also told me that HaShem was perfect. But if he was jealous, and jealousy was bad, then he couldn’t be perfect. Because jealousy was bad and a perfect being couldn’t be bad...right?

And the light bulb came on then and there: All this guy in the sky stuff was bullshit, just like Santa Claus.

I never again believed in the invisible space buddies. Yeah, I went hardcore Judaism for a while in the 90s, but that was a “connecting with my heritage” thing, not religious. I haven’t been to Temple in at least 20 years now, and it’s been even longer since I’ve attended a xian ritual. Maybe the 80s, when the USAF tricked us into attending the holy roller service during basic. I got even by spending the rest of Sunday mornings sitting outside and smoking until a service was over. Nobody was ever the wiser for it.

yellerpup

(12,263 posts)
7. Walking home with my parents after Easter services.
Wed Sep 25, 2019, 08:36 AM
Sep 2019

I was about 5 years old and concentrating on my feet, trying not to slip on the shards of broken sidewalk between our house and the church. I had been bored with the sermon and I was wondering why they only told one story. Ever. Every time we went to church it was the same old thing. And then, I remembered the main pitch of the story, "Whosoever believeth in the lord JC will surely be born again." And my thought was, I sure hope I get a better momma and daddy next time.

When I was a teen, my aunt who taught bible class, invited me to just leave the church, "If I couldn't stop asking questions and just Believe." I knew my whole life, but I was released from any pretense forever after.

Boomer

(4,249 posts)
8. For me, that is such a strange perspective
Wed Sep 25, 2019, 01:05 PM
Sep 2019

I never "realized" I was an atheist, I simply was one. Even as a child I heard all the nice stories about various religious gods from Zeus to the Almighty Christian god, and I found them interesting, sometimes quaint, but I never took them seriously.

My atheism wasn't reached through a process, it was the default. I started there and never encountered anything persuasive enough about any religion to convince me otherwise.

Boomer

(4,249 posts)
12. That's probably why I don't relate to the Atheist Movement
Fri Sep 27, 2019, 04:05 PM
Sep 2019

Organizing around being an atheist never appealed to me. It would be like joining a club for people who don't climb mountains or people who aren't deep sea divers. It's not an interest, it's a non-interest, and it's so broad that there's no real commonality with other people who hold that same non-interest. In all other respects we could be diametrically opposed.

For people who left their religions, I think there actually is more of a perception of common experience. That whole process of absorbing, then rejecting, a certain set of values and principles and assumptions can provide shared emotional histories. But I can't directly relate to that myself.

I do, however, see the need to fight against specific intrusions of religion on my secular life or violations of the separation of church and state. So although I don't participate in organization that are focused on "being an atheist", I have contributed to specific causes in which religion has impinged on my civil liberties.

Gelliebeans

(5,043 posts)
9. Non religious family but
Fri Sep 27, 2019, 03:33 PM
Sep 2019

When my father took me to space museum in San Diego, I started getting very interested in space and realized just how small “we” are.

Piasladic

(1,162 posts)
15. When I "rebelled"
Sun Oct 27, 2019, 07:38 PM
Oct 2019

and tried praying to Jesus to come into my soul, and it felt like a farce (9 years old)

dna80

(10 posts)
21. preparation for marriage
Wed Jan 22, 2020, 10:01 AM
Jan 2020

Being told by a priest that birth control was out of the question.
My parents had 8 children, this was not going to be my fate.
I started questioning all of it.

Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Atheists & Agnostics»The moment you realized y...