An attempt of a proof.
God is defined as infinite. Infinitely strong, infinitely, wise, infinitely perfect, whatever.
Infinite.
The problem with infinity is that it is a perfectly fine and workable concept on a mathematical/logical/philosophical level, but not on a physical level. That is why all proofs for God's existence are entirely mathematical/logical/philosophical, not physical.
It is not possible to prove any infinity on a physical, experimental, empirical level. It is ON PRINCIPLE impossible to experimentally determine whether something is infinitely big or infinitely small:
1. No instrument has an infinitely large scale to measure against and no instrument has an infinitely small resolution to measure against.
2. For simple statistical reasons (the math of statistical moments), the only way to accurately describe a physical entity/system, is with an infinitely large data-set. No finite data-set can ever accurately describe what a physical system truly is like. It can approximate physical reality (which is the underlying logical reason behind the whole "scientific method"
, but it can never accurately describe it.
So...
It is not possible to determine via a physical experiment whether a person/entity/thing is infinite/God.
It is not possible to determine via a physical experiment whether or not God does or doesn't exist.
Another infinite person/entity/thing could maybe determine whether or not God exists, but a finite physical experiment can not do that.
And this is a problem for God. Being infinitely strong, infinitely wise, infinitely perfect is a MASSIVE problem for God.
God is supposed to be perfect. If the existence of a thing is not experimentally provable, then how can it be perfect?
God can either be infinitely strong/wise/whatever or infinitely perfect, but not both.
= new reply since forum marked as read
