Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Bleacher Creature

(11,434 posts)
Mon Aug 23, 2021, 01:09 PM Aug 2021

I genuinely don't get the "calling for prayers" thing.

Every time some right wing antivaxxer gets COVID, they post a tweet asking for prayers. It's obviously not limited to COVID, but seeing it so much now got me thinking, and it truly makes no sense.

Is the idea that some higher power is keeping tabs of the number of prayers a person receives, and if that number exceeds a certain threshold they get cured? And if so, can a person pray for you twice (or more), or is it calculated on a per person basis? Also, does the quality of the person praying taken into account?

I'm seriously not trying to be flip here, but I really don't get it.

14 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I genuinely don't get the "calling for prayers" thing. (Original Post) Bleacher Creature Aug 2021 OP
When I was in Catholic school they told us Mr.Bill Aug 2021 #1
Next thing you know, they'll put Mr.Bill Aug 2021 #2
If the person dies, God called them home. If they live, Croney Aug 2021 #3
I have one story to tell you leftieNanner Aug 2021 #4
R. Craig Hogan in Your Eternal Self describes many of the experiments conducted which Karadeniz Aug 2021 #8
Good Point leftieNanner Aug 2021 #9
If you want a serious answer here is a link Tomconroy Aug 2021 #5
Interesting thought: does God use points and algorithms like tic toc? Under The Radar Aug 2021 #6
There's an app for that! PSPS Aug 2021 #7
prayers don't cost anything, and they can't hurt. rampartc Aug 2021 #10
They Can and Do Hurt EmmaLee E Dec 2021 #14
The thing of it is, if yo go all in to the God thingy... 3Hotdogs Aug 2021 #11
It's important to Jesus that you are popular enki23 Aug 2021 #12
There's a bible verse in the gospels RFCalifornia Oct 2021 #13

Mr.Bill

(24,790 posts)
1. When I was in Catholic school they told us
Mon Aug 23, 2021, 01:11 PM
Aug 2021

that children's prayers had a higher value because children were so pure. Factor that one in.

Croney

(4,923 posts)
3. If the person dies, God called them home. If they live,
Mon Aug 23, 2021, 01:15 PM
Aug 2021

the prayers worked. They have their win-win firmly in place.

leftieNanner

(15,690 posts)
4. I have one story to tell you
Mon Aug 23, 2021, 01:18 PM
Aug 2021

I have a similar attitude about this, but...

A number of years ago, a woman I knew in our community fell and cut her leg. As most parents do, she cleaned it up and ignored it (something she would never have done if her children had been injured). Anyway, it became infected and ultimately went septic. She was in the hospital and her family was summoned (one from overseas) to say their final goodbyes. One of her close friends gathered 20 or so women from the area and invited all of us who loved her to meet at her church for a prayer circle and meditation. The minister spoke briefly and then we all sat in the darkened church with candles in our hands. We spoke silently to whatever god or spirit we believed in and asked for her to be healed.

That night her raging fever broke and the doctors turned the tide on the infection. She survived.

Whether global "pray for me" requests are effective, I do not know.

But Barbara is still with us.

Karadeniz

(23,417 posts)
8. R. Craig Hogan in Your Eternal Self describes many of the experiments conducted which
Mon Aug 23, 2021, 02:26 PM
Aug 2021

strongly suggest that the power of thought, Mind, is not entirely derived solely from the human brain and that Mind indeed affects physical reality. This makes me wonder if the power of prayer really needs a god connection or if it's thought alone that is the operative manipulator.

 

Tomconroy

(7,611 posts)
5. If you want a serious answer here is a link
Mon Aug 23, 2021, 01:19 PM
Aug 2021

To Chapter 19 of William James' Varieties of Religious Experience:

http://xroads.virginia.edu/~Hyper/WJAMES/ch19.html

It's pretty long and not easy going though. The topic of prayer begins at paragraph ten.

Here is an article specifically on petitionary prayers:

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/petitionary-prayer/

Most likely we pray for the effect it has on ourselves.

EmmaLee E

(196 posts)
14. They Can and Do Hurt
Thu Dec 2, 2021, 04:31 PM
Dec 2021

When medical treatment is disregarded.

But I suppose we know this from COVID vaccination rates.

3Hotdogs

(13,394 posts)
11. The thing of it is, if yo go all in to the God thingy...
Mon Aug 23, 2021, 03:33 PM
Aug 2021

Joe is sick.
God controls everything.
God, not only knows that Joe is sick, God made Joe sick.

so.......

If I pray for God to get Joe's sorry ass out of hospital, am I praying to undo God's will?

If so, will my ass take his place in the E.R.?

enki23

(7,794 posts)
12. It's important to Jesus that you are popular
Mon Aug 23, 2021, 07:58 PM
Aug 2021

Or maybe the act of calling for prayers is what is important. Actually receiving them isn't. In that case, *being* popular isn't important, but putting on the correct front for Jesus is important even if both you and he are aware it's a sham.

Or.... maybe it's not about Jesus at all, and is instead a desire to be or appear popular to fellow members of the fandom.

RFCalifornia

(440 posts)
13. There's a bible verse in the gospels
Fri Oct 8, 2021, 03:08 PM
Oct 2021

Not sure where or which one, but basically it says when more than one are gathered in Yeshua ben Yusuf's name, the power of prayer is stronger

Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Atheists & Agnostics»I genuinely don't get the...