History of Feminism
Related: About this forumI can't help but wonder: If we were to elect a female President, would it make any difference
in how this country views/treats its women and girls and the policies enacted towards us?
I really thought that electing our first African American President might make some difference in how our nation's people of color are treated, but if anything, it seems to have both emboldened and "empowered" the worst racists in society. Admittedly, this conclusion is fresh off the whole sad Trayvon Martin saga, but not solely based on that...
So, if we were to elect a Hillary Clinton or Elizabeth Warren or other capable female to the Presidency, would it make any real and long term difference?
geek tragedy
(68,868 posts)group of men.
CTyankee
(65,441 posts)geek tragedy
(68,868 posts)Not sure what my thought process behind this post was, it was almost 2 years ago.
unblock
(54,312 posts)who makes it normal.
obama is the first black president, and we're seeing a lot of reaction to that. the fact that he's black is very palpable and relevant to much of the reaction to him. eventually we will have another black president. *that* president will likely be judged on the usual crap and not so much on skin color.
same for a woman president. not until the second woman president will it seem normal.
so yes, the first one has a rough time of it and on the whole it's hard to see the clear gain. but when the second one comes along the gain is obvious, and it wouldn't have been possible without the first.
highmindedhavi
(355 posts)...she did not take money from Banks/Wall Street
MadrasT
(7,237 posts)I believe it would provoke an even stronger backlash against women than we are seeing now, much as you describe the situation with Obama seeming to add fuel to the racists' fires.
I won't vote for someone based on their genitals, but I sure would love to see Elizabeth Warren run.
(I can't believe we have people running around on DU blaming the Zimmerman verdict on a female jury. Holy fuck, a bigger load of sexist crap has never been seen on DU in my memory.)
hlthe2b
(107,189 posts)CrispyQ
(38,723 posts)As to the OP, here's how it will go.
The media will focus on what she wears, how she looks, how she interacts with other men, how she interacts with other women, but most comparisons will be gender based.
Repub male politicians, the vile ones in particular, will not be able to keep their mouths shut. We will hear even more appalling garbage spewed. It will bring out the worst in them.
At the state level, even more will be incensed that a woman is in the White House. They will 'show us' by carrying out even more draconian anti-woman legislation.
Among the people, if she's thin & pretty, a lot of men will dismiss her authority but say how much they would like to fuck her. If she's not thin, a lot of men will dismiss her authority and call her a cow & that's the kindest thing they will say. Most of these men are repubs, but we have them in our party, too.
For young women & girls, it will be good, a ceiling broken. It will always be a struggle, but there is always, "If someone else did it, I can too." I know a woman who makes six figures selling Mary Kay & that is her mantra.
on edit: I would never vote for someone based on gender.
Skittles
(160,724 posts)that right there tells us that sexism and misogyny is even more pervasive than racism
fredamae
(4,458 posts)if we take a look at how they've treated a black man........
So aside from the fact I cannot support HRC for POTUS because of her policies/positions--the 1% factor--etc Imagine how they'd treat Her..
I am very disappointed in this POTUS, I make no bones about it--but it's His Policies and what I believe to be bad decision making that is Out of Touch with Us.
IDGRA What Gender or Color of a person -they'd better be "good to All people with good intent" as a leader
I LOATHE how they've disrespected, insulted, demeaned and tried to set him up for crime and scandal. There is No excuse.
Whether we like his/her politics (or not) is All that should ever be at issue.
malthaussen
(17,813 posts)It would, short-term, indubitably serve to harden opposition/hatred.
Long-term? We don't really know, yet.
-- Mal
Scuba
(53,475 posts)hlthe2b
(107,189 posts)these two women. And, yes, I do believe that much of that response is independent of "who" that particular first female President might be.
Scuba
(53,475 posts)truebluegreen
(9,033 posts)Opposition to her candidacy by the big boys in charge was defused by the fact that she pushed their agenda.
Scuba
(53,475 posts)truebluegreen
(9,033 posts)And the stories in the press more than 3 years out touting her "inevitability" and how Texas is in play if she runs etc etc etc scares the bejeezus outta me.
Another status-quo defending place-holder--female or not--is so not what we need.
BainsBane
(55,066 posts)but it won't be a panacea.
ismnotwasm
(42,486 posts)Specially on social media; it would help in the way things are becoming transparent, and while be easier to post sexist or racist crap, it's also easier to call it out
As far as difference, I think we have a systemic political problem or two that will take more than one women, or person of color, to be elected to fix---and that over a generation or so.
Response to hlthe2b (Original post)
Name removed Message auto-removed
ismnotwasm
(42,486 posts)Last edited Sat Mar 14, 2015, 06:18 AM - Edit history (1)
It'd be a historical event, but real change will take a very long time
geek tragedy
(68,868 posts)The Obama presidency certainly hasn't made racism go away, but it did change the way black people see the country and their relation to it.
YoungDemCA
(5,714 posts)eridani
(51,907 posts)Nobody who disapproves of the imperial warfare state (and says so publicly) will be allowed within 100 miles of the White House.
villager
(26,001 posts)...well, we've seen what happens then, eh?
Agnosticsherbet
(11,619 posts)We sold not let that deter our work towards change.
fredamae
(4,458 posts)make a difference.
It would get Worse, imo.
Any deviation from THEIR ideal POTUS ie: a Soulless Wealthy Old White Man Who Will Auto-Sign Kochs/Wall Street/1% Legislation into law, is Never going to be acceptable to the GOP imo.
Thinkingabout
(30,058 posts)as president. I think in the case of Hillary will be a great president and in the future she will be the standard on which future presidents will try to serve.
drray23
(8,044 posts)When Barack Obama got elected, people thought, maybe naively that race relations would improve. It went the other direction.
Having a woman president would certainly bring the issues in the forefront so that would be positive. Whether or not, this would have an immediate impact is not clear, at least to me.