and it's cluttering the place up. Not in a good way, either.

Some pretty obvious trolling from new DU members, but a lot from long time DUers.

Creative speculation is fun!

It's pretty much what the entire "mystery" genre is built on.

But it does get in the way of life when people jumble it together with boring old reality.

It was the best of times, it was the worst of times

People just can't help making up their own theories if they can't get all the facts immediately.

so I would like a place to read it, and if it helps make the rest of the site more "clutter-free" for other users, why not?

We need a place where "I have a theory" really means "I have a wild-ass guess."