Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

willamette

(182 posts)
Sat Jun 1, 2024, 06:34 PM Jun 2024

Three movies and a book that I saw/read recently, that I keep thinking about

The latest two first: I just finished reading (listening to) The Warmth of Other Suns, by Isabel Wilkerson. It is both dramatized biographies and an overview of the Great Migration of Southern Negro-classified people to the North and West. I enjoyed the life stories, but the parts that keep recurring to me, at various times during the day, during various activities, is the amount of new information imparted in close to a first-person telling, of the realities of living in the Post-Reconstruction Jim Crow states, and the continuing themes in the other states. As a child, I used to ask myself, "Why didn't they just leave." Even after the difficulty in leaving an emotionally abusive long-term marriage, I still didn't connect the dots that leaving the South was difficult and dangerous, perhaps fatally so.

There were two eye opening things that I wonder why I didn't already know or figure out (??? What is it that makes not knowing uncomfortable things so easy? Is it not knowing, or refusing to know?) that occur to me now, as I write this. The first was the determined, consistent, and successful cheating of sharecroppers to ensure that they could neither obtain their own land, or leave the place on which they worked. The second was how Slavery 2.0 was enforced on everyone, no matter their classification, and whether or not they were in the actual South (those states that went to war with democracy to maintain their hold on the lives and labor of those classed as Negro), or just South-thinking adjacent. The most striking story was of making a multi-day highway trip from Louisiana to California, and trying to get a place to sleep for the night. Even when the motel owner seemed to want to rent to the traveler, and not just for the income, but because it was the Golden Rule thing to do; he couldn't bring himself to do it, due to the hell that he adjudged would rain ("reign" works here too ...) down on him from his fellow motel/hotel owners in his community. Even, he said, if the traveler were to "sneak away" in the pre-dawn darkness so as not to be seen leaving the establishment. I saw the movie Green Book; I knew about the prohibitions. What I didn't know, was that the saying, "All it takes for evil to succeed is for good to do nothing" was being demonstrated over and over again, all over. Now, I have cogitated, thinking about the holocaust, how willingly, or not, I'd step forward to help Jewish-classified people, if I would have been German-classified. The German enforcers would hang your children from your own balcony before killing you, if you were caught aiding and abetting.

So, immediately upon finishing this book, the same day even, I watched the movie The Banker (2020 Anthony Mackie, Samuel L. Jackson, Nia Long). I think I may have caught wind of this movie here on Democracy Underground. It was beautifully made, with great acting, and many of the things written about in the aforementioned book were playing out on the the screen. In living color, so to speak. The story, of Negro-classified bankers trying, and mainly succeeding, to live the American Dream in spite of the American White Supremacy was delightful. The movie was (loosely, I'm guessing) based on a true history. I say loosely, because there was a bit of a save at the end, after the confiscation of assets that seemed like way more than the alleged monetary discrepancy that had been "discovered." Of note is that a White-classified partner was forced to betray them under threat of total confiscation of assets and a 50 year prison sentence. This is the above theme playing out once again. "I want to live by the Golden Rule, but this god damned White Supremacy won't let me." No wonder it is so hard to fight that demon intertwined with structure.


---------------------------

The next movie that has been revisiting me lately is Quiz Lady (2023 Awkwafina, Sandra Oh, Will Ferrell) . This delightful romp manages to address neurodivergence, LGBTQIA+ themes, siblings coming through for each other, missing-dad coping strategies, and quiz shows.


-----------------------------

And, the third movie: Moving On (2022 Lily Tomlin, Jane Fonda). It's a low-key, pretty serious movie, interspersed with bouts of slapstick comedy à la It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World. It is about two old, in both senses, friends as they face their last years. One subplot follows the Me Too theme, and how these traumatic events live on for decades and decades, and another is about a young person trying to figure out their gender, and why it is a problem for their parents. Lily Tomlin's character is there to supply love, appreciation, and understanding based on that person's character, not on which toys or clothes they choose. For me Moving On was truly moving.

6 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Three movies and a book that I saw/read recently, that I keep thinking about (Original Post) willamette Jun 2024 OP
Warmth of Other Suns wonderful important book Stardust Mirror Jun 2024 #1
I read Caste first willamette Jun 2024 #3
Thanks for this post. ariadne0614 Jun 2024 #2
That is the insidiousness of the book banning, etc. willamette Jun 2024 #4
I'm just glad my eyes were opened before I leave this world. ariadne0614 Jun 2024 #5
Thanks for the book recommendation! willamette Jun 2024 #6

willamette

(182 posts)
3. I read Caste first
Sat Jun 1, 2024, 07:12 PM
Jun 2024

I could have used "caste" instead of "class," but I didn't think of it. I also like that class comes from classification, which indicates that it is an arbitrary system.

ariadne0614

(1,831 posts)
2. Thanks for this post.
Sat Jun 1, 2024, 07:10 PM
Jun 2024

All of your suggestions look wonderful. I’ll search through my library for the audio book, and watch every movie I can stream. The one I’m listening to now is almost over.

I was born mid-last century, and raised (after age 7) in a lily-white ranch house suburb in one of the most segregated cities in the Midwest. My grandparents moved from Norway and Mexico in the second decade of the 20th century, but I didn’t discover my Mexican half till I was 21. My parents wanted us to think of ourselves as “Americans,” which I didn’t question till the cultural revolution of the 60s. Now I realize it was a code word for “White.”

Sometimes I’m ashamed of how long it took me to get curious about the racism that permeated every aspect of American life. There’s so much more information now, especially via the arts. It’s fascinating to dive into the lived experience of other actual Americans, including my own Mexican half. I feel enriched every time I do.

Anyway, thanks again for your thoughtful words.

willamette

(182 posts)
4. That is the insidiousness of the book banning, etc.
Sat Jun 1, 2024, 07:35 PM
Jun 2024

In my opinion, by banning the books that tell us about how our compatriots live and experience the world, we don't learn about the past or the present. By banning Critical Race Theory (learning about Structural Racism in our institutions) and history that includes all of us, people in any of the targeted/omitted castes/classifications don't soak in the knowledge that their treatment is wrong, and that others have fought, and sometimes won, these battles. Here's how to do it: see (hypothetical) page 43. I often think that there should be more articles and books about how people escaped the ghettos, extermination camps, and roundups. To me, that is more useful information than how little space they had in the barracks.

I too was raised in that time frame in a mysteriously all white caste subdivision. It was VA subsidized, but just for that caste. I just thought that there weren't any marginalized people who wanted to live there. Nary a word was heard about segregation or red-lining. When I later found out that my father was a bigot, and that he prevented my mother from selling the family home to a Negro classified family, I was astonished. Had I been British, I would have been gob-smacked. He never let on that all of that nasty behavior was hiding inside of him, just waiting to come out. Lordy, I wonder what he'd have done had he lived to see The Convicted Felon holding office.

Is the book that you are listening to now interesting? Might I like to read it ... ?

Thank you for your kind words (Thank you for the Thank you).

ariadne0614

(1,831 posts)
5. I'm just glad my eyes were opened before I leave this world.
Sat Jun 1, 2024, 08:13 PM
Jun 2024

The book I’m reading is Love in the Time of Cholera, by Colombian author Gabriel Garcia Marquez. It takes place on an unnamed island in the Caribbean. My daughter told me about reading one of his books multiple times, which made me curious to check him out. She read One Hundred Years of Solitude. I’ll definitely read that one too. His writing is magical.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9712.Love_in_the_Time_of_Cholera

willamette

(182 posts)
6. Thanks for the book recommendation!
Sat Jun 1, 2024, 08:17 PM
Jun 2024

I may have looked it up once, but it's not in my To Be Read files. I'll give it another look.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Movies»Three movies and a book t...