Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

fairfaxvadem

(1,254 posts)
Tue Dec 26, 2017, 11:56 PM Dec 2017

Darkest Hour comments...

So, for those of you who are WWII afficiandos, you might be a little frustrated. At least I was. Yes, the movie takes the usual Hollywood liberties, often due to compressed time which is common, and this is no different. Gary Oldham, for those who have read enough history, IMHO, captured the very quirkiness of WC. There have been many comments made about his racism, etc., not undeserved at all. WC was who he was, generationally, social status, the whole British Empire enchilada.

So, Darkest Hour. I very much enjoyed it, but I wish filmmakers, when they make these movies, would do a better job at the end of the credits when they show the “postscript.” Yes, the US entering WWII was the only salvation with money and manpower. BUT. Americans need to be reminded that Great Britain was left to their own devices for years. They were at war in 1939. FDR had to circumvent the isolationist laws to try to even help until Pearl Harbor, which wasn’t until 1941, and even then, we had the Pacific Theatre and North Africa to start. No troops in Europe. My dad started off in Tunisia in 1942 until invasion of Europe in 1944.

So all this is to say that fine, make the Darkest Hour, but make it a more forceful reminder and a learning moment that these were frightening days for the Brits. We weren’t there to save the day for quite a long time and they deserve the praise of the fortitude they showed in those early years of the war when there was a very real possibility that GB wouldn’t survive Nazi Germany, whether militarily or by political decisions.

Rant off.

9 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Darkest Hour comments... (Original Post) fairfaxvadem Dec 2017 OP
And don't forget the Russians. pangaia Dec 2017 #1
A whole other thread!! fairfaxvadem Dec 2017 #2
Russia was not attacked by Germany until June 1941. Sneederbunk Dec 2017 #3
The bastards? That was Stalin. rusty quoin Dec 2017 #8
did he have any MPs* or US senators demanding he resign for being a sexist? msongs Dec 2017 #4
I think I know what you are saying. rusty quoin Dec 2017 #5
Thank you, Rusty fairfaxvadem Dec 2017 #6
Yeah...whats wrong with real history. It doesnt make me feel bad. I like truth. rusty quoin Dec 2017 #7
Message auto-removed Name removed Feb 2018 #9

fairfaxvadem

(1,254 posts)
2. A whole other thread!!
Wed Dec 27, 2017, 12:07 AM
Dec 2017

Did much of my undergrad on WWII, plus mom, dad and uncles all served, so try to keep myself restrained on comments. Darkest Hour mostly focused on the early internal Brit politics. Appease or War. It seems laughable now, but entertaining an intermediary from Mussolini seemed reasonable to some at the time, as the film reflects. And then his hanging some years later...you just never know. Careful with the friends you choose, I guess.

Sneederbunk

(15,177 posts)
3. Russia was not attacked by Germany until June 1941.
Wed Dec 27, 2017, 12:08 AM
Dec 2017

The bastards had a non-agression pact with Germany from 1939. They got part of Poland when Germany started the war.

 

rusty quoin

(6,133 posts)
8. The bastards? That was Stalin.
Wed Dec 27, 2017, 01:29 AM
Dec 2017

You are thinking like back then. Stalin and Hitler were complete assholes.

The people had to follow. Let’s make sure we don’t have to follow Trump.

msongs

(70,210 posts)
4. did he have any MPs* or US senators demanding he resign for being a sexist?
Wed Dec 27, 2017, 12:13 AM
Dec 2017

*members of parliament often referred to as MPs

 

rusty quoin

(6,133 posts)
5. I think I know what you are saying.
Wed Dec 27, 2017, 12:42 AM
Dec 2017

Like a lot of Americans like to say...we saved your British asses, they don’t know history.

If it wasn’t for the British we would not have had the cushion of them dying to defeat the axis. Cushion is the wrong word, and it pisses me off when we Americans act like we saved the world. If Britain did not save themselves, alone, except with American cargo, what would have happened? It was the only military in Western Europe left to fight Germans.

We were the allies, and we worked together like nothing else has ever been done to beat the axis.

fairfaxvadem

(1,254 posts)
6. Thank you, Rusty
Wed Dec 27, 2017, 01:02 AM
Dec 2017

I by no means want to diminish the sacrifices that many of our faimilies made during WW2. I have a history in photographs from all theatres of war that I and my siblings cherish and reflect on. My parents are buried at Quantico, having both served our country.

My frustration isn’t with our patriotism, but with our general lack of historical accuracy and appreciation of how things really were. I don’t think the unvarnished truth undermines one iota the turning point that occurred with the US entering the war. Yes, the Brits and French lobbied for an earlier US invasion of Europe, but we determined our own course, for the most part. My dad was there from beginning to end w/Patton. He had some interesting observations when he was in the mood.

I can never learn enough.


Response to fairfaxvadem (Original post)

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Movies»Darkest Hour comments...