General Discussion

The Grand Illuminist

(1,700 posts)

83. For all those who are against the death penalty...

Reply to Laura PourMeADrink (Original post)

Mon Jan 9, 2023, 08:35 AM

Jan 2023

Last edited Mon Jan 9, 2023, 02:58 PM - Edit history (1)

I ask this. Where is the line drawn when the person is too dangerous to be kept alive?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

142 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Are you in favor of the death penalty? [View all] Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 OP

I consider it state murder. My husband and I told our kids should we be murdered we do not want Demsrule86 Jan 2023 #1

I agree it is a cold-blooded killing. It's being done in the name of the people. Walleye Jan 2023 #4

That is how I feel and considering the injustices in our judicial system...it is just barbaric. Demsrule86 Jan 2023 #27

Exactly! Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #44

No. But above all because we can't reverse it and we make mistakes Hortensis Jan 2023 #134

I remember writing an essay in junior high,my first firm political position, anti-death penalty Walleye Jan 2023 #2

+1. I haven't looked it up but there was a period when it was illegal. Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #7

I sure am NOT. CaliforniaPeggy Jan 2023 #3

+1 Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #8

Exactly! WVGal1963 Jan 2023 #25

Putting an irrevocable result in the hands of the AleksS Jan 2023 #5

Having done a capital appeal qazplm135 Jan 2023 #26

Some very heinous acts rock my beliefs regarding this issue but I am against it Deuxcents Jan 2023 #6

I hear you. Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #10

I'm 99% against, but there are a few so heinous that I don't object AZSkiffyGeek Jan 2023 #15

I'm against it because it doesn't 'deter' anything... rubbersole Jan 2023 #68

I feel the same. OnionPatch Jan 2023 #100

I would like to see it HIGHLY restricted as well. roamer65 Jan 2023 #20

Ditto. BTK needs to be in the ground Blue_playwright Jan 2023 #38

I think about how many times Ted Bundy escaped from jail... Laffy Kat Jan 2023 #43

I don't pay much attention to serial killers bc too scary, so I had No Idea he'd Escaped! Woah! electric_blue68 Jan 2023 #54

Yep, both times from Colorado jails. Laffy Kat Jan 2023 #64

Gah! electric_blue68 Jan 2023 #118

Sends wrong message: poli-junkie Jan 2023 #9

State sanctioned murder PoindexterOglethorpe Jan 2023 #11

+1 Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #12

No Bleacher Creature Jan 2023 #13

So you kill someone for killing someone? spanone Jan 2023 #14

So you hold someone against their will for holding someone against their will? TheProle Jan 2023 #113

These results don't fit with articles I've posted about prisoners executed iemanja Jan 2023 #16

That's interesting!!! Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #33

The 484th person Texas executed had an IQ of 61. Laffy Kat Jan 2023 #46

Really? Wow. Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #56

I would say that people are not Disaffected Jan 2023 #66

I disagree with that GenThePerservering Jan 2023 #110

I agree obamanut2012 Jan 2023 #86

Or a straight question about it attracts more responses (just votes) than comments muriel_volestrangler Jan 2023 #111

In theory yes, not in practice. SYFROYH Jan 2023 #17

+1 progressoid Jan 2023 #29

+2 Blue_playwright Jan 2023 #40

+3 Shrek Jan 2023 #78

So you are pro DP obamanut2012 Jan 2023 #87

The problem is that they can't tighten it enough to eliminate error. I'm convinced of that. SYFROYH Jan 2023 #97

That's why I hit "other" Dorian Gray Jan 2023 #108

I don't like the mistakes, that's for sure. dchill Jan 2023 #18

That's My Issue ProfessorGAC Jan 2023 #112

Generally, NO FoxNewsSucks Jan 2023 #19

So you are pro DP obamanut2012 Jan 2023 #89

Lol, so you are not against the death penalty! USALiberal Jan 2023 #121

Only in certain cases is it a good thing jmowreader Jan 2023 #21

So you are pro DP, and think murder is "a good thing" obamanut2012 Jan 2023 #90

Why do you want that to happen it's not a deterrent at all USALiberal Jan 2023 #122

Definite 'no' for the death penalty. Talitha Jan 2023 #22

Don't like it, Igel Jan 2023 #23

That's an interesting thought. Life in prison without Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #34

When answering the question remember that SCOTUS justices say you don't have a right RockRaven Jan 2023 #24

I am absolutely opposed. It's barbaric. Ocelot II Jan 2023 #28

Nope. Solly Mack Jan 2023 #30

No edhopper Jan 2023 #31

+1 Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #36

No. n/t GP6971 Jan 2023 #32

No. But there are exceptions to every rule. LakeArenal Jan 2023 #35

With nitrogen gas and fentanyl, it can make a very humane comeback. Frasier Balzov Jan 2023 #37

Nope....not under any circumstances....n/t Upthevibe Jan 2023 #39

+1 Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #42

In some cases nt doc03 Jan 2023 #41

No. brer cat Jan 2023 #45

No, under no circumstances, not for any reason. Stinky The Clown Jan 2023 #47

Some criminals want the death penalty for themselves. Timothy McVeigh, Oklahoma bomber wanted to b keithbvadu2 Jan 2023 #48

Many more no's sarisataka Jan 2023 #49

Philosophical here, without the specific monstrosities of a crime JT45242 Jan 2023 #57

it is barbaric Skittles Jan 2023 #50

In certain cases and only with iron clad proof of guilt. TigressDem Jan 2023 #51

No. And there are some henious crimes that try my patience. electric_blue68 Jan 2023 #52

Yes, but only if the criminal wants to live, BigmanPigman Jan 2023 #53

El Chapo won't get it, but I feel he is one of the rare ones who deserves it. LeftInTX Jan 2023 #107

I am not proud of my answer but, yes, there are those who deserve to have the state end their lives bottomofthehill Jan 2023 #55

You are a very kind person and you make an extraodinarily Laura PourMeADrink Jan 2023 #58

Maybe it was just too close to home, maybe because of the random nature of those who died bottomofthehill Jan 2023 #59

Understandable response grantcart Jan 2023 #60

Never. Even when they deserve it. Just not a power the state should hold. Maru Kitteh Jan 2023 #61

no... myohmy2 Jan 2023 #62

After serving on a couple of juries, The system is not absolute enough for an absolute end. mackdaddy Jan 2023 #63

There are people who should be or should have been executed.... Kissinger, Rice, asshole in Idaho 3Hotdogs Jan 2023 #65

It's claudette Jan 2023 #67

No. Not in favor of revenge (that's what it is) flvegan Jan 2023 #69

I am 100% opposed to the death penalty. ShazzieB Jan 2023 #70

I am still waiting to hear an argument that would sway nevergiveup Jan 2023 #71

No. When I hear the term "pro-life," that's what it means to me. Rhiannon12866 Jan 2023 #72

Not at 16 when a family member was murdered Warpy Jan 2023 #73

No. It is state ritual murder, and without guarantee that no innocent will be executed DFW Jan 2023 #74

I'm basically against it, due in large part to my feeling that Abolishinist Jan 2023 #75

I'm against Capital Punishment, but that' not the banner I want to march behind. philly_bob Jan 2023 #76

Great post, exactly what I believe. n/t MicaelS Jan 2023 #99

Common misconception inthewind21 Jan 2023 #101

Only in the rarest of cases DenaliDemocrat Jan 2023 #77

What prompted you to do this poll? akbacchus_BC Jan 2023 #79

I'm struggling with my words here... MissMillie Jan 2023 #80

Many have given the most significant reasons to oppose it above. But there is an Scrivener7 Jan 2023 #81

No but I don't care about those who commit heinous crimes. Kaleva Jan 2023 #82

For all those who are against the death penalty... The Grand Illuminist Jan 2023 #83

Could you give an example? How is that status determined? WhiskeyGrinder Jan 2023 #88

That is what prison is for, Sport obamanut2012 Jan 2023 #91

I cannot think of anyone sarisataka Jan 2023 #93

Nobody's too dangerous to be kept alive. Everyone is mere flesh and blood and can Wingus Dingus Jan 2023 #98

Terrorists who operate out of prison LeftInTX Jan 2023 #106

They'd be in the Supermax. Wingus Dingus Jan 2023 #109

That won't stop written communications. The Grand Illuminist Jan 2023 #119

For those inthewind21 Jan 2023 #102

Besides a Sith Lord, who else fits that description? Polybius Jan 2023 #103

Too dangerous to be kept alive??? What the hell does that mean. USALiberal Jan 2023 #123

How would you personally The Grand Illuminist Jan 2023 #126

For those whom are for the DP - when has it ever deterred future heinous crimes? tenderfoot Jan 2023 #139

Nor has prison and jail. The Grand Illuminist Jan 2023 #140

So EVERYONE in prison is going to commit more crimes once released tenderfoot Jan 2023 #141

Never said everyone. The Grand Illuminist Jan 2023 #142

I have been opposed to the death penalty all my life, Doc_Technical Jan 2023 #84

Murder by the State is still murder obamanut2012 Jan 2023 #85

I have no moral compunction against it, but it must NEVER be in error and justice is not perfect. sir pball Jan 2023 #92

No.... but..... Happy Hoosier Jan 2023 #94

Not in favor of it. Our tax dollars should not be used to kill people. ecstatic Jan 2023 #95

I try and let my better angels rule Elessar Zappa Jan 2023 #96

Not really. Torchlight Jan 2023 #104

No mvd Jan 2023 #105

For me, only under very narrow and extreme circumstances Mr.Bill Jan 2023 #114

Example??? USALiberal Jan 2023 #124

Seial Killers, child murder, solid witnesses and other proof, such as DNA, Mr.Bill Jan 2023 #131

In the case of child murderers and serial killers, yes PlanetBev Jan 2023 #115

Absolutely not. Xolodno Jan 2023 #116

Not in this justice system that railroads innocent defendants. GoodRaisin Jan 2023 #117

Not any more. I favor a lifetime of solitary confinement tritsofme Jan 2023 #120

I like how Washington handled it with Gary Ridgeway Kennah Jan 2023 #125

When they're proud of it MurrayDelph Jan 2023 #127

I used to be very much in favor of it... SKKY Jan 2023 #128

Yes Lurker Deluxe Jan 2023 #129

In Very Extreme Circumstances, Yes Deep State Witch Jan 2023 #130

I'm opposed to the death penalty, primarily because it is ... Whiskeytide Jan 2023 #132

I went with "Yes" though my answer is a little more nuanced than that. Jedi Guy Jan 2023 #133

No. Caliman73 Jan 2023 #135

You got the only death penalty clearly stated in the constitution. The Grand Illuminist Jan 2023 #136

I am not EnergizedLib Jan 2023 #137

I am against the death penalty. Silver Swan Jan 2023 #138