Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

AndyS

(14,559 posts)
Tue Feb 14, 2023, 08:11 PM Feb 2023

I have an admission and a request. [View all]

Last edited Tue Feb 14, 2023, 08:47 PM - Edit history (1)

I take pictures and I write about gun violence. It's all I do. Gun violence is an anguish inducing and painful topic for me. Many have made me acutely aware of how difficult a struggle it is to reduce this carnage. I've long since given up on preventing it, I'd be happy to simply see it diminish a bit.

I watched Sandy Hook unveil on live TV with a 4 year old grandchild in my lap and two others in class a block away. I did the same with Parkland. Uvalde was on my TV in real time. I saw it all. My nephew died by gun suicide. A friend's daughter attempted the same. I've had a gun pointed at me. More than once. This is a personal thing to me and I'm not entirely rational about it.

That was the admission.

Now for the request.

For those who feel like responding to my posts with what may seem like a pragmatic outlook that nothing will ever be done, that nothing will ever change, that I should just accept it and go on with life I would ask two things; consider looking a survivor in the eyes as you compose your words. How would those comments be received by a parent of Sandy Hook or Parkland or Uvalde or one of the hundreds of other schools where shootings have ended promising lives as they just began? How would it make them feel to be told all is in vane and those deaths will never lead to anything redeeming? Choose your words carefully.

The second thing I'd ask is for you to take the advice of your mother. If you can't say something nice and supportive just STFU.

81 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
that earned a heart. N/t gay texan Feb 2023 #1
It makes me nuts when people are all "Nothing will work". Maraya1969 Feb 2023 #2
In my red union shop the gun nuts are rampant hydrolastic Feb 2023 #7
I have never said "nothing will work" brooklynite Feb 2023 #8
In my lifetime, they said the same thing about gay marriage. old as dirt Feb 2023 #10
The Constitution doesn't say anything about marriage; it DOES say something about firearms... brooklynite Feb 2023 #16
Bowers v Hardwick (nt) old as dirt Feb 2023 #17
The Constitution means what somebody says it does. AndyS Feb 2023 #12
"we need to change who interprets it" brooklynite Feb 2023 #23
Yes. THIS. hlthe2b Feb 2023 #35
Your comments abiut SCOTUS are spot on! Grumpy Old Guy Feb 2023 #41
Exactly this. Glaisne Feb 2023 #52
Amen. MontanaMama Feb 2023 #3
I love your post, too, MM. JudyM Feb 2023 #63
Yes! MontanaMama Feb 2023 #71
Thank you. crickets Feb 2023 #4
Nice. Succinct. Compelling. Easterncedar Feb 2023 #5
You know where I am on this, Andy. Because of you . . . CaliforniaPeggy Feb 2023 #6
When MADD got started, it wasn't going to "work" gratuitous Feb 2023 #9
+1 betsuni Feb 2023 #18
Thanks, gratuitous. That's a great example. nt crickets Feb 2023 #19
You make an important point. CTyankee Feb 2023 #39
Drunk drivers didn't have a lobbying group News Junkie Feb 2023 #64
No, but there is a liquor lobby. Mr.Bill Feb 2023 #67
LOL DENVERPOPS Feb 2023 #69
It has to change The Blue Flower Feb 2023 #11
I'm so old I remember when there was an assault weapon ban in this country. Pobeka Feb 2023 #13
+1 llmart Feb 2023 #15
Yep. Same here. Sad to say. calimary Feb 2023 #47
I'm so old I remember when an assault rifle was one that could go from semi to fully automatic. Ligyron Feb 2023 #73
I stand with you on that. llmart Feb 2023 #14
Time was.. Permanut Feb 2023 #20
Thank you for this reminder, AndyS Hekate Feb 2023 #21
Right there with you, Andy. Had a glock pointed 3 inches from my chest 10 yrs ago. ancianita Feb 2023 #22
I hope this doesn't sound negative... rubbersole Feb 2023 #24
"take the advice of your mother. If you can't say something nice and supportive just STFU." LudwigPastorius Feb 2023 #25
I'm largely on side but I have mixed feelings Jarqui Feb 2023 #26
I am with you... Trueblue Texan Feb 2023 #27
All I know, beyond all the horrific events, is that Laura PourMeADrink Feb 2023 #28
My grandson is alive, walking & talking, miraculously duhneece Feb 2023 #29
I can say nothing more important than what you just conveyed. hlthe2b Feb 2023 #34
And my story, without the miracles, is far too common duhneece Feb 2023 #38
I expect you get and deserve a good bit of support. BootinUp Feb 2023 #30
Never give up. summer_in_TX Feb 2023 #31
K&R betsuni Feb 2023 #32
I would never tell you that. My perspective dates to 24/7 coverage of Columbine, a few miles away hlthe2b Feb 2023 #33
Preach, brother HAB911 Feb 2023 #36
Huge K&R. n/t OneGrassRoot Feb 2023 #37
K&R pandr32 Feb 2023 #40
K&R - Good post AndyS. c-rational Feb 2023 #42
I agree. Good post. nt jrthin Feb 2023 #43
Thank you Wild blueberry Feb 2023 #44
So In Other Words, RobinA Feb 2023 #45
Total capitulation is not discussion and I assure there is not a fucking thing AndyS Feb 2023 #46
Happy talk? Evidently I am missing something. Butterflylady Feb 2023 #48
SCOTUS has made America exponentially much more dangerous due to Bruen. NJ uses to have very strict Pepsidog Feb 2023 #49
some people have opinions you won't like treestar Feb 2023 #50
Irritating know it all posts are the norm Tumbulu Feb 2023 #51
maybe but whaddya do when someone treestar Feb 2023 #58
The author can deal with them Tumbulu Feb 2023 #74
why would the motive be hassling for fun? treestar Feb 2023 #76
I can tell them what I think of their obstruction and collaboration AndyS Feb 2023 #55
that's right treestar Feb 2023 #59
Surely you recognize that we're playing defense on this issue, maxsolomon Feb 2023 #53
Money yes, momentum no. AndyS Feb 2023 #54
What you call 'support' is more likely despair. maxsolomon Feb 2023 #56
We agree on the difficulty. AndyS Feb 2023 #60
maybe they do really feel that way treestar Feb 2023 #61
Given that not a single mass shooting seems to dampen the enthusiasm for guns, PoindexterOglethorpe Feb 2023 #57
Yep. Some people have so little imagination treestar Feb 2023 #62
Exactly DENVERPOPS Feb 2023 #70
So even just the car helped them see treestar Feb 2023 #77
Thank you for your post DENVERPOPS Feb 2023 #80
I agree, but not without Mr.Bill Feb 2023 #68
Of course. PoindexterOglethorpe Feb 2023 #72
Of course, though at this point, they treestar Feb 2023 #78
Thank you for your post DENVERPOPS Feb 2023 #81
I can see where this would feel crazy. I don't have that going on but still feel despondent JudyM Feb 2023 #65
The future has one thing going for it genxlib Feb 2023 #66
I agree Tumbulu Feb 2023 #75
Yes. The fire drills and civil defense drills treestar Feb 2023 #79
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I have an admission and a...