Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

orleans

(35,353 posts)
Thu Dec 26, 2024, 11:34 PM Dec 26

in an attempt to soothe my soul (when i was a teenager) my mother used to say [View all]

"everything happens for a reason"
--to help me thru those angsty rollercoaster years of love and loss, of on again/off again friendships, relationships that ran hot and cold and some that were utterly devastating

it was said with the same intent as the phrase when one door closes another door opens
or look at it on the bright side
or every cloud has a silver lining

it was something my mom tried to offer me to give me hope that things will get better

"everything happens for a reason" (with the implication being that there was a good reason for the bad thing to happen but there is something better ahead)

(ah youth, right?)

while in the moment i was doubtful and skeptical i'd still try (sooner or later) to come around, wanting to believe her, to take it to heart in order to comfort myself thru the lows

then, at seventeen, a dear friend of mine, also seventeen, was murdered. (her killer was never caught btw)
that changed everything.

suddenly that consolation phrase of "everything happens for a reason" meant absolutely nothing
it felt like one big lie

after that, the next time my mom told me "everything happens for a reason" i yelled at her to never say that to me again. (and she never did.) i demanded to know what could possibly be the reason my friend had been brutally murdered; because some guy was mad at her or just mad at the world, or fucking crazy? i guess those are reasons but they aren't good reasons, justifiable reasons, rational reasons

there was no cloud with a silver lining. she was dead. dead, dead, dead

i broadened my perspective: the holocaust.
no good reason, no justifiable reason, nothing rational at all; crazy people, mad men, go along to get along "good" germans
there was no cloud with a silver lining
not a whisper. not a hint. not a bit.
and that horror and tragedy and devastation has lived on for generations

justice? maybe sometimes but there is no guarantee of it and it's not foolproof.
one word: trump

karma?
yeah...where is that? "what goes around comes around"
really? i don't think so.
one word: trump

i wish, i wish, i wish i was fourteen, fifteen, sixteen again with my mother telling me "everything happens for a reason" and i could assume it was a good reason, and, in spite of my skepticism, i would try with all my heart to believe what she said was true, that wrongs would be righted, that the universe was fair and just, that things would work out, and everything would be alright.

(god, i miss my mom. every day)

if you got this far then thanks for reading. i kept debating if i should just delete all this. i know it's a ramble and train of thought piece where i seem to jump the tracks a few times. sorry, i've been under the weather lately (good excuse, right?) (but true) and this was how my brain was gliding along tonight.

44 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Definitely don't delete. Enjoyed reading and get it. Silent Type Dec 26 #1
100% ZDU Dec 29 #32
'It's always darkest before the dawn.' Dad elleng Dec 26 #2
I used to hear the same things from mother SheltieLover Dec 26 #3
question: in the fullness of your adult experience of life, (and lessons) stopdiggin Dec 26 #4
oh yes, of course i understand what she was trying to say orleans Dec 27 #5
and, as I said - you had EVERY right in the world .... stopdiggin Dec 27 #12
Oh my dear orleans . . . CaliforniaPeggy Dec 27 #6
Sometimes for no understandable reason StarryNite Dec 27 #7
yes. nt orleans Dec 27 #8
So many good reminders here. Hope22 Dec 27 #9
thank you for your lovely reply nt orleans Dec 27 #11
Your despair is part of a process nuxvomica Dec 27 #10
Every year in December I re-read a book by Terry Pratchett called Hogfather... Hekate Dec 27 #13
that's beautiful and very profound, hekate. thank you for that. nt orleans Dec 27 #18
You are most welcome. May the new year be gentle on you Hekate Monday #44
just put Hogfather on hold at library. there is a DVD of it as well. PUt it on hold too. Amaryllis Dec 27 #21
I also watch the movie once a year... Hekate Dec 28 #22
Never got into Discworld. Do you like it? Amaryllis Dec 29 #23
Very much, or I wouldn't recommend it. It took me awhile to "get" Pratchett back in the '90s... Hekate Dec 29 #24
Have you read Good Omens, Neil Gaiman? Amaryllis Dec 29 #25
Oh yes. I read it because Terry Pratchett was co-author, and after that I read more of Gaiman Hekate Dec 29 #28
Did you see the TV series they made of it? Cant remember if it was NEtflix.... Amaryllis Monday #34
It was on Amazon Prime, so I joined for a month (free) and binge-watched it twice through Hekate Monday #36
I liked it a lot. there is always the thing where the character look different than how you imagined, but it was very Amaryllis Monday #39
The first was just called Good Omens when it came out in 2018 or 2019. Now it's called ... Hekate Monday #42
Thank you for posting this reminder of how good an observer of humans Sir Terry was. GoneOffShore Monday #37
You are welcome Hekate Monday #43
"everything happens for a reason"--I think that's horseshit. raccoon Dec 27 #14
I dunno. no_hypocrisy Dec 27 #15
There is always a chain of events which amount to a "cause" of WHY something happened, but... Martin Eden Dec 27 #16
I applaud and agree wholeheartedly. vanlassie Dec 29 #27
God's will, everything happens for a reason, karma is a bitch, etc. ThreeNoSeep Dec 27 #17
cause and effect - yes, i get that. orleans Dec 27 #19
Thank you for starting this discussion. yellow dahlia Dec 27 #20
Agree Meowmee Dec 29 #26
"When one door closes another door opens mahina Dec 29 #29
Humans need a reboot. Take care. Joinfortmill Dec 29 #30
There IS a reason for a happening and sometimes, 'what goes around... Septua Dec 29 #31
Few things make me angrier that the sanctimonious empty bullshit of that "everything... 3catwoman3 Monday #33
It's what i needed right now. DiverDave Monday #35
serendipity i guess. please take care. nt orleans Monday #38
You are very fortunate to have had a good Mom like her. Your Mom. Your friend Clouds Passing Monday #40
No reasons, no meaning ismnotwasm Monday #41
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»in an attempt to soothe m...