Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: FoxNews has to be dismantled [View all]MarineCombatEngineer
(17,985 posts)128. ....
I think Fox should be forced to close, as well as other media outlets. The purpose of the First Amendment is to protect the public's right of access to information, not to protect the interests of billionaire monopolists.
Well, thank god your not in a position to impose such unconstitutional nonsense.
BTW, do you know the 5 elements of the 1A?
Here's a free clue, it's not just about freedom of speech,
https://jideas.org/basic-freedoms-guaranteed-by-the-first-amendment/
1. Freedom of Religion
For centuries, the US has been referred to as the land of the free. What this means is that Americans are free to do whatever they want. To this end, the constitution through the First Amendment offers them the Freedom of Religion. With it, the government is prohibited from punishing you for practicing whatever religion you consider appropriate for you. However, although you are guaranteed this freedom, you do not sacrifice any human being.
What is more, this freedom prohibits the government from forcing any American to practice a particular kind of religion. Through this guarantee, you can worship the deity of your choice without having to worry about being ridiculed. Additionally, you are free to sue anyone who ridicules or punishes you for practicing your preferred religion. Without the amendment, the government would probably have pushed one religion down everyones throat.
2. Freedom of Speech
Secondly, the First Amendment guarantees the Freedom of Speech to all Americans. What this means is you are free to share your thoughts regarding any issue under the earth publicly and on any platform. As you do this, the constitution protects you from being subjected to any form of punishment, especially by the government. However, over the years, the American courts have grappled with various issues regarding this guaranteed freedom.
Most critically, the courts have sought to discover or interpret the limits of this freedom. Despite all the litigations regarding this freedom in the courts, First Amendment prohibits the government or any of its agencies from denying you this right. Nevertheless, the courts may determine that you have abused this freedom if your speech threatens the country through a clear and present danger.
3. Freedom of the Press
Freedom of the Press shares several principles with Freedom of Speech. However, the courts have differentiated the two by prohibiting the government from censoring any information prior to publishing or writing. What this means is the government can never force anyone including the media from publishing any information that the public deserves to know unless it proves that the details are a threat to national security.
Similarly, your freedom would cease in the following instances:
Libel
Defamation of character
Obscenity
Fighting words
Perjury
True threats
Blackmail
Incitement to break the law
Plagiarizing copyrighter material
Soliciting others to commit crime
4. Freedom to Assemble
Over the years, the government has sought to disperse groups of people gathering to protest certain actions. Normally, this leads to intense debates regarding whether their rights were violated. That is exactly the scenario the First Amendment envisaged when it guaranteed Americans Freedom to Assemble. What is more, the amendment protects the rights of Americans to plan and participate in peaceful protests or to associate with anyone you like.
5. Freedom to Petition the Government
It is common for Americans to feel the government needs to be pressed to make changes on certain issues. You are guaranteed the Freedom to Petition the government at the county, state, or federal level. Moreover, you can do this alone or as part of a group without having to face consequences of your actions. For all of this, you have the First Amendment to thank for guaranteeing you such freedom. With this freedom, you can hold the government accountable.
The constitution, through the First Amendment, has guaranteed these freedoms since 1792.
For centuries, the US has been referred to as the land of the free. What this means is that Americans are free to do whatever they want. To this end, the constitution through the First Amendment offers them the Freedom of Religion. With it, the government is prohibited from punishing you for practicing whatever religion you consider appropriate for you. However, although you are guaranteed this freedom, you do not sacrifice any human being.
What is more, this freedom prohibits the government from forcing any American to practice a particular kind of religion. Through this guarantee, you can worship the deity of your choice without having to worry about being ridiculed. Additionally, you are free to sue anyone who ridicules or punishes you for practicing your preferred religion. Without the amendment, the government would probably have pushed one religion down everyones throat.
2. Freedom of Speech
Secondly, the First Amendment guarantees the Freedom of Speech to all Americans. What this means is you are free to share your thoughts regarding any issue under the earth publicly and on any platform. As you do this, the constitution protects you from being subjected to any form of punishment, especially by the government. However, over the years, the American courts have grappled with various issues regarding this guaranteed freedom.
Most critically, the courts have sought to discover or interpret the limits of this freedom. Despite all the litigations regarding this freedom in the courts, First Amendment prohibits the government or any of its agencies from denying you this right. Nevertheless, the courts may determine that you have abused this freedom if your speech threatens the country through a clear and present danger.
3. Freedom of the Press
Freedom of the Press shares several principles with Freedom of Speech. However, the courts have differentiated the two by prohibiting the government from censoring any information prior to publishing or writing. What this means is the government can never force anyone including the media from publishing any information that the public deserves to know unless it proves that the details are a threat to national security.
Similarly, your freedom would cease in the following instances:
Libel
Defamation of character
Obscenity
Fighting words
Perjury
True threats
Blackmail
Incitement to break the law
Plagiarizing copyrighter material
Soliciting others to commit crime
4. Freedom to Assemble
Over the years, the government has sought to disperse groups of people gathering to protest certain actions. Normally, this leads to intense debates regarding whether their rights were violated. That is exactly the scenario the First Amendment envisaged when it guaranteed Americans Freedom to Assemble. What is more, the amendment protects the rights of Americans to plan and participate in peaceful protests or to associate with anyone you like.
5. Freedom to Petition the Government
It is common for Americans to feel the government needs to be pressed to make changes on certain issues. You are guaranteed the Freedom to Petition the government at the county, state, or federal level. Moreover, you can do this alone or as part of a group without having to face consequences of your actions. For all of this, you have the First Amendment to thank for guaranteeing you such freedom. With this freedom, you can hold the government accountable.
The constitution, through the First Amendment, has guaranteed these freedoms since 1792.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
165 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
"I'll bet you that a good 90% of these people that supposedly voted for him couldn't actually tell you a policy position
Demovictory9
May 2025
#1
Joe Rogan was mocking Biden for talking about airports in the revolutionary war.
Gary 50
May 2025
#84
"Musk stole the election" The prevailing theory I saw here was that he used Starlink
Bonx
May 2025
#4
I'm interested in hearing what anticompetitive behavior FoxNews is engaging in
onenote
May 2025
#148
Could Vladimir come here and spin up a new channel called VladTV and that would be perfectly legal
oldmanlynn
May 2025
#76
Can he start a broadcast channel? No. Could he start a satellite delivered network? Probably.
onenote
May 2025
#90
Yeah, but there was Republicans who stepped up and said that's enough. You can't obstruct justice
oldmanlynn
May 2025
#75
I think the regulations should apply to satellite and cable as well if they don't
Meowmee
May 2025
#140
Ok, so Faux gets banned, not going to happen, but just for shits and giggles,
MarineCombatEngineer
May 2025
#71
Yes, but what you seem to be missing is that in '69, cable, internet and satellite were non existent,
MarineCombatEngineer
May 2025
#116
I imagine dismantling media outlets that disagree with the state would fit the definition
MichMan
May 2025
#40
If it's that inconsequential because so few people watch, why all the angst here and elsewhere then?
MichMan
May 2025
#64
Yeah, start holding your breath on that suggestion now and if wishes were horses,
elocs
May 2025
#48
If the problem is "the feeble minds of Middle America and Rural America" then the larger problem is democracy.
Jim__
May 2025
#54
It would be nice if we had a reasonable media that accurately labeled right wing propaganda as such.
unblock
May 2025
#55
Absolutely spot on. Nothing will change until Fox is dismantled or the total collapse of our society.
Pepsidog
May 2025
#72
Thank you. If people would pay attention to what the Trump FCC is doing they might think twice
onenote
May 2025
#92
How do you defeat the incomprehensible? How do people not choose democracy? How do you fix stupid?
NowsTheTime
May 2025
#85
90 percent of Krasnov's campaign ads in my red district were about one policy position.
GoodRaisin
May 2025
#93
Those ads ran incessantly in my area harping on two things, VP Harris supporting surgery for trans inmates and when
Silent Type
May 2025
#96
Thing is, we handled that very poorly. The campaign never pushed back on the ad
GoodRaisin
May 2025
#105
Don't watch or care for FOX, but I'd oppose dismantling FOX as unconstitutional and we might be next.
Silent Type
May 2025
#94
I couldn't care less if you advocate this, that's the great thing about our Constitution.
MarineCombatEngineer
May 2025
#134
No thank you. Everyone has the right to watch what they want, and no voices should be shut down.
Groundhawg
May 2025
#142
How would you propose we dismantle Fox News within the parameters of the 1st Amendment and
kelly1mm
May 2025
#154