Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Metaphorical

(2,522 posts)
55. Strauss & Howe had it wrong
Wed Jun 18, 2025, 08:50 PM
Jun 2025

I've long felt that generations should be measured peak to trough and vice versa, rather than at the mid-points, something that become VERY much an issue from about 1971 on. The "trough" of the Boomers was actually 1936, and it's notable that most of the big rock legends, from Buddy Holly, Elvis, the Beatles, the Rolling Stones, etc., were all born within a couple of years of 1936, while most of the tech luminaries - Gates, Jobs, Ellison, etc., were all born in or around the peak of the nominal Boomer generation in 1954-55. 1954-1972 is considerably more internally consistent, as is the next cohort (Gen Z Prime) from 73-91, and from 1992 to 2008, which would be the Millenials Prime. Technologically that also fits: Boomer Primes were born during the Radio Era, GenX Primes (Jones) were the TV Era, GenZ Prime were the PC Era, Millennials Prime were the Internet Era, and, Alphas Prime (after 2008-2025) are the mobile era. It's a little early but Beta Primes (will likely be the AI Generation), where Prime indicates a time shift of about 9 years back.

I've written extensively about this, most recently here: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/why-we-get-generations-wrong-matters-kurt-cagle/


Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Gen X baby! FirstLight Jun 2025 #1
Me too 😁 MustLoveBeagles Jun 2025 #10
Me three! Polybius Jun 2025 #13
Me four! Basso8vb Jun 2025 #27
Make it five! synni Jun 2025 #38
How about six! marmar Jun 2025 #54
or seven? Maru Kitteh Jun 2025 #69
Jan 68 !! IbogaProject Yesterday #86
I am as well Bettie Jun 2025 #79
Millenial here sakabatou Jun 2025 #2
1944 I wasn't very "silent' though. Ping Tung Jun 2025 #3
1943 here Bohunk68 Jun 2025 #53
Me too, 1943 Jilly_in_VA Jun 2025 #77
Yeah, I don't see that at all PatSeg Jun 2025 #78
Do these results reveal that DU is unsustainable? Frasier Balzov Jun 2025 #4
This message was self-deleted by its author PeaceWave Jun 2025 #7
Not sure where you're at lovesfruit Jun 2025 #15
This is along the lines of what I was wondering... snot Jun 2025 #34
During the recent Korean election synni Jun 2025 #40
It definitely was older people mostly in my town Tree Lady Jun 2025 #47
This message was self-deleted by its author questionseverything Jun 2025 #39
DU has been around for decades. W_HAMILTON Jun 2025 #60
Reddit TacosUberAlles Jun 2025 #75
This message was self-deleted by its author W_HAMILTON Jun 2025 #82
Probably so.... but message boards like this are kinda 1999ish. Jack Valentino Jun 2025 #63
One of the reasons why I post here AZProgressive Jun 2025 #76
Older people are political and vote Demovictory9 Jun 2025 #65
Boomer and happy to be one. MuseRider Jun 2025 #5
Boom Boom. maveric Jun 2025 #6
I belong to the Blank Generation misanthrope Jun 2025 #8
LOL maxsolomon Jun 2025 #24
the younger part of the Boomers should be the Blank Generation DBoon Jun 2025 #29
I also like Blank Generation, but Generation Jones seems to have caught on. tinrobot Jun 2025 #57
"London Calling" is the "White Album" of the punk generation DBoon Jun 2025 #61
Richard Hell is 75 years old. maxsolomon Jun 2025 #83
Late Boomer. "Generation Jones". maxsolomon Jun 2025 #9
Same here -misanthroptimist Jun 2025 #22
I'm early Gen Jones Metaphorical Jun 2025 #52
Me too SouthernIrish Jun 2025 #49
Yeah, I was home watching cartoons while they were at Woodstock. tinrobot Jun 2025 #56
19 years. The Boomer birthyears are from 1946 to 1964. Celerity Jun 2025 #67
Well, at least now I know DFW Jun 2025 #11
Why add the option for Gen Beta? Polybius Jun 2025 #12
God bless that brave baby for grabbing Mom's phone and raising their voice. Xavier Breath Jun 2025 #17
Sorry; snot Jun 2025 #44
Joker?? Whatever, you crusty Gen Xer TheProle Jun 2025 #46
Lol Polybius Jun 2025 #62
Gen X. Xavier Breath Jun 2025 #14
I'm Gen X too, but I'm the opposite Polybius Jun 2025 #19
This message was self-deleted by its author PeaceWave Jun 2025 #16
Gen X! flvegan Jun 2025 #18
Gen X proud patriot Jun 2025 #20
Millennial. Passages Jun 2025 #21
less than 6 months shy of 1965, I claim Generation X. eShirl Jun 2025 #23
I am similar misanthrope Jun 2025 #25
You just missed out on all the cool toys of the 80's though! Polybius Jun 2025 #31
Gen Jones....not on your list so I passed /nt sdfernando Jun 2025 #26
I almost wish we just label people by the decade they were born JanMichael Jun 2025 #28
So far, nobody 28 years old or younger has responded. CoopersDad Jun 2025 #30
I (born late 1996) self identify as a Zillennial. Also, the Gen Beta years, if we go by the now-standard post-Boomer '16 Celerity Jun 2025 #32
I was born in 1964 into a Boomer family but intheflow Jun 2025 #33
you are technically Generation Jones Skittles Jun 2025 #36
Same. When I was in college, too, I was always told I was in Gen X, and all Mike 03 Jun 2025 #73
I was born in 1957 but feel the same way indigovalley Jun 2025 #80
you really should include GENERATION JONES Skittles Jun 2025 #35
I fall in the BoomX gen. PuraVidaDreamin Jun 2025 #37
Generation Jones. Crunchy Frog Jun 2025 #41
Xennial róisín_dubh Jun 2025 #42
Why are Rebl2 Jun 2025 #43
see my reply #34 above snot Jun 2025 #45
Generation Jones Ex Lurker Jun 2025 #48
Boomer at the start of the 2nd third of the Boomer Gen without separating Gen Jones... one year shy of first yr GJ - '53 electric_blue68 Jun 2025 #50
Generation Jones here... WarGamer Jun 2025 #51
Strauss & Howe had it wrong Metaphorical Jun 2025 #55
Gen X The Third Doctor Jun 2025 #58
Hi snot. As my name says. 55 .I was born in 1955 and I am a Boomer. debm55 Jun 2025 #59
"Xennial" here sir pball Jun 2025 #64
I'm literally between X and millenial. Initech Jun 2025 #66
I'm generation "Fuck that noise". We're known for mocking authority and giggling. Lots of giggling. Solly Mack Jun 2025 #68
Gen X. Wingus Dingus Jun 2025 #70
Boomer here. Harry Truman was POTUS in 1952. ProudMNDemocrat Jun 2025 #71
I Rec'd this poll, because I feel like it' helps to understand the generational growth in membership. msfiddlestix Jun 2025 #72
Technically a boomer, area51 Jun 2025 #74
Boomer here along with boomer spouse mountain grammy Jun 2025 #81
Technically a boomer Danmel Jun 2025 #84
Nope. (n/t) Iggo Jun 2025 #85
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»What "Generation" are you...»Reply #55