Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Disaffected

(6,257 posts)
18. Do incorrect arithmetical calculations count as hallucinations?
Thu Jul 10, 2025, 12:01 AM
Jul 2025

Likely not but it is an interesting situation anyhow.

I recently asked ChatGPT a series of questions related to hydrogen/boron fusion and as part of one answer it calculated the amount of boron that would be needed to generate the world's current electricity consumption. The calculation was off by a factor of about 1,000.

I asked why the error and how could I trust anything else in the replies if it makes such simple errors. The reply was it was a result of how large language models work and, if you want precise calculations i.e. correct calculations, you have to specifically request it.

BTW, it also give wrong factual information, not related to calculations.

However, one thing I do find rather astonishing is how it will provide sophisticated computer programming code from a rather simple English description of what one wants the program to do and, it seems to be pretty dammed good at it. I have read that in some organizations, around 90% of the code produced is by AI and the programmer's task is mainly to go over and check the code for correctness. I'm not sure at all I would want to make a career of computer coding now as it looks like the demand for programmers might soon dramatically drop.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

OK, I'm anything but a high tech guru, boonecreek Jul 2025 #1
Frightening? Beyond frightening! There are server banks for single companies using the energy of small cities ... marble falls Jul 2025 #3
I had a hunch it was worse than I thought. boonecreek Jul 2025 #7
A few links: highplainsdem Jul 2025 #5
And thank you for the links. boonecreek Jul 2025 #8
Garbage in garbage out. enough Jul 2025 #2
An unfiltered mishmash of garbage and fact with no editing protocol for truth or fact. marble falls Jul 2025 #4
Those newer AI models are also worse for the environment. See this: highplainsdem Jul 2025 #6
one word: B.See Jul 2025 #9
What the Ukraine war seems to have developed into a lab for. marble falls Jul 2025 #21
Forbidden Planet 1956............... Lovie777 Jul 2025 #10
Exactamundo. I had that thought myself. marble falls Jul 2025 #20
Anybody here Faux pas Jul 2025 #11
This is why all these companies purple_haze Jul 2025 #12
Companies that try to rely heavily on AI The Madcap Jul 2025 #13
I can probably give you the reason for the hallucinations. PurgedVoter Jul 2025 #14
A good explanation RainCaster Jul 2025 #17
Do incorrect arithmetical calculations count as hallucinations? Disaffected Jul 2025 #18
Grammar error -- "but" should be "so". nt eppur_se_muova Jul 2025 #15
Thanks! marble falls Jul 2025 #16
AI bots are COMPLETELY incapable of actual logic William Seger Jul 2025 #19
It's logic absent volunteered intent. It doesn't meant to be right or wrong, it looks to bridging a gap with ... marble falls Jul 2025 #22
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»A.I. Is Getting More Powe...»Reply #18