Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Renew Deal

(85,251 posts)
3. I asked ChatGPT if this is a big deal.
Sat Dec 20, 2025, 11:08 PM
Dec 2025

This is what it told me:

Short answer: yes, it’s a big deal operationally for NIST and some dependent systems — but it is not a global time crisis, and most people and systems will not notice.

Here’s how to think about it, from “headline scary” to “practical impact.”

What actually failed (and why it matters)

What’s down is NIST’s Boulder-based atomic ensemble and Internet Time Services, not UTC itself.

Key points:

The atomic clocks didn’t suddenly become “wrong” — they lost their traceable reference and distribution path.

NIST is correctly taking servers offline to avoid distributing bad time, which is exactly what a responsible time authority does.

This is a power + infrastructure resilience failure, not a physics or clock-design failure.

The real risk here is silent time drift, which NIST is explicitly preventing by disabling the servers.

What is not happening

Let’s kill a few scary interpretations:

❌ UTC is not broken

❌ GPS time is not broken

❌ Financial markets are not about to lose timestamp integrity

❌ TLS certificates are not going to globally fail

❌ The internet is not about to desynchronize

UTC is a composite international time scale maintained by the BIPM using data from dozens of labs worldwide (USNO, PTB, NPL, SYRTE, etc.). NIST Boulder is important — but not a single point of failure.

Recommendations

7 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Can't see Threads posts canetoad Dec 2025 #1
There is a status monitoring system that shows them down as of 8PM MT Renew Deal Dec 2025 #4
OMG !1! dweller Dec 2025 #2
I asked ChatGPT if this is a big deal. Renew Deal Dec 2025 #3
Please don't post chatbot answers here. That answer could be wrong in lots of ways, but you can't highplainsdem Dec 2025 #9
As someone who worked in time & frequency for 25 years, the answer is pretty spot on... Wounded Bear Dec 2025 #11
Hey, another time nerd! cos dem Dec 2025 #12
I will continue to do it and label it when I do. Renew Deal Dec 2025 #13
The only reason ChatGPT appears to work at all is the theft of the world's intellectual property, and it highplainsdem Dec 2025 #15
When somebody announces that it's a chatbot answer, that is sufficient synni Dec 2025 #17
This message was self-deleted by its author highplainsdem Dec 2025 #18
No, that isn't sufficient, because many people are still not aware that chatbot answers can be filled highplainsdem Dec 2025 #19
Speaking of illegal training data ... DU posts can be alerted on for violations of copyright law. If AIs routinely ... eppur_se_muova Dec 2025 #21
I'd prefer just a clear-cut rule against posting anything AI-generated, with an exception made for highplainsdem Dec 2025 #22
So would I, but some here are strangely enthusiastic about II (Imitation Intelligence, which is what AI really is) ... eppur_se_muova Dec 2025 #23
It can be tempting for people to use AI if they think it saves them time, or makes them appear more highplainsdem Dec 2025 #27
No worries. Permanut Dec 2025 #5
We have now officially entered dweller Dec 2025 #6
Does anybody really know what time it is? Orrex Dec 2025 #7
(Care) does anybody really care? Ol Janx Spirit Dec 2025 #10
The time is... Jacson6 Dec 2025 #14
We only have enough time edhopper Dec 2025 #24
Good excuse to be late for work Monday. JohnnyRingo Dec 2025 #8
Music Video - Time - Phil Keaggy Jacson6 Dec 2025 #16
I like this Time song and asked the kids to play it when I croak. TheBlackAdder Dec 2025 #20
Love Alan Parsons. Unfortunately, he's now having to deal with AI-using frauds: highplainsdem Dec 2025 #25
I've been a big fan of his since the 1970s lapfog_1 Dec 2025 #28
Time is but the stream I go a-fishing in. usonian Dec 2025 #26
My daughter who lives in Boulder has told me for two weeks about the power being shut off. Not a surprise for someone efhmc Dec 2025 #29
Will the universe notice? Probably not. Norrrm Dec 2025 #30
Anyone who relies on those servers for PCI DSS compliance could be in for a world of hurt dickthegrouch Dec 2025 #31
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The atomic ensemble time ...»Reply #3