Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

canetoad

(20,692 posts)
39. I saw Charlotte Corday mentioned above
Wed Feb 18, 2026, 10:07 PM
Feb 18

There's been several informal experiments conducted to ascertain consciousness after guillotining. Amazingly, a fairly recent study was undertaken here.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9930870/
"The Most Gentle of Lethal Methods": The Question of Retained Consciousness Following Decapitation

Abstract

Since the development of the infamous guillotine in the French Revolution, physicians have debated how long consciousness persists in decapitated heads. Fueled by anecdotes of severed heads that blink, blush, and appear to retain intelligence, numerous experiments have investigated this macabre subject for nearly 250 years. In this paper, we examine the evidence, both historical and modern, and ultimately conclude that, while the truth may never be fully known, all evidence appears to indicate that loss of consciousness appears to occur within seconds of decapitation. The rumors that circulated through the European consciousness during the Terror of the French Revolution appear to be just that - curious urban legends from an awed and terrified public.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Pft.. I'm still waiting for my consciousness to start. Orrex Feb 18 #1
😁 Floyd R. Turbo Feb 18 #2
LOL BComplex Feb 18 #5
get better coffee! DBoon Feb 18 #17
You mean tRump might be aware of the incredible celebrations after his death? Whyisthisstillclose Feb 18 #3
🤗 Floyd R. Turbo Feb 18 #4
I love creative thinking bigtree Feb 18 #15
Bwaaaaah hahaha😀 malaise Feb 18 #16
He'd probably just think he had been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize posthumously. generalbetrayus Feb 18 #22
LOL! He'll still be a dimwit after death, won't he? Whyisthisstillclose Feb 18 #23
Snort! electric_blue68 Feb 18 #38
Keep the electricity going and I'll be like Google on my cell phone bucolic_frolic Feb 18 #6
🤔 Floyd R. Turbo Feb 18 #7
I lost consciousness looking at that link. ornotna Feb 18 #8
👩🏼‍⚕️ Floyd R. Turbo Feb 18 #9
Paywall but, Disaffected Feb 18 #10
Weird! I don't get a paywall. Floyd R. Turbo Feb 18 #19
Here is a free archive link: Celerity Feb 18 #28
I think I go against the grain with a lot of DU on religious/spiritual issues so I look at this and think "sounds right" ck4829 Feb 18 #11
Edgar Allan Poe wrote about taphophobia; the fear of being buried alive, stemming from the anxiety of being incorrectly sop Feb 18 #12
Also makes me think of Poe's short story BuddhaGirl Feb 18 #24
reign of terror - paragraph 2 tells of charlotte cordray ................. rampartd Feb 18 #13
YIKES! snot Feb 18 #27
... SSJVegeta Feb 18 #14
Gunga, gungagalunga shakeyslim Feb 18 #18
"So I got that going for me" MustBeTheBooz Feb 18 #36
A friend reads about near death experiences told by Eben Alexander, MD. usonian Feb 18 #20
Wow! I'll delete it. Thanks! Floyd R. Turbo Feb 18 #21
Just because you retain some consciousness... OC375 Feb 18 #25
Doesn't surprise me. We don't know the half of it. I'm sure. Joinfortmill Feb 18 #26
This message was self-deleted by its author wcmagumba Feb 18 #29
Consciousness is highly overrated. Ray Bruns Feb 18 #30
When we die, they change the sheets and get ready for a new patient. I ain't the Dalai Lama. twodogsbarking Feb 18 #31
Silliness ABC123Easy Feb 18 #32
10 Minutes 38 Seconds in This Strange World --- A strange and disturbing and beautiful story erronis Feb 18 #33
Cool! When I die I will make sure Netflix is on then I can binge watch some movies before I Go! Jacson6 Feb 18 #34
Just be careful what you say after the plug is pulled! Totally Tunsie Feb 18 #35
I get "minutes" but not "hours". Laffy Kat Feb 18 #37
I saw Charlotte Corday mentioned above canetoad Feb 18 #39
Wow! pattyloutwo Feb 19 #40
When I have a chance, I'm sure I'll be able to personally investigate the matter, but I probably won't... NNadir Feb 19 #41
Yeah, I'm not so sure about that, really. MineralMan Feb 19 #42
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Something else to lose sl...»Reply #39