Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

bigtree

(94,556 posts)
39. did they get what you wanted out of this republican majority?
Mon Apr 27, 2026, 08:45 PM
Monday

...that's the question.

We can argue out our differences in a majority, compromise and move forward. That's how progressive change has always happened.

The new fad of trying to burn down the house(s) every election is an ignorant and sophomoric pursuit that predictably does little to account for the ultimate outcome; the numbers; the math that puts republicans in the position to dictate the direction of our government and our nation.

It makes little sense, and is a profound misunderstanding of the utility of the party. We're a coalition of diverse and often disparate interests and concerns from myriad regions of the nation who band together to advance the many things that we agree on, and work to reconcile the rest into action or law.

Our democratic system makes room for our elected officials to either sit on their hands and object, or compromise with each other to move legislation forward. Democrats decide on what they will legislate by way of a caucus of members in their respective chambers.

It's not a dictatorial system, but a deliberative one that intends to build coalitions around what these many interests and their constituents want. That's what their leaders are challenged to accomplish; as unified a coalition as they can manage.

That's why THEY vote to advance leaders who can bridge or accommodate often competing notions and determinations on how to move forward. That expectation of our elected Democrats of their leaders isn't going to produce a firebrand, or someone who wears their personal politics on their sleeve.

They want someone who will represent to the public THEIR consensus of opinion as expressed in the caucus meeting they hold before votes and at the beginning of legislative cycles.

One thing that's always frustrating to me is how individual legislators, especially heads or ranking members of committees, are celebrated for their tenacity and toughness, while the leaders or the managers of the party who deliberately placed them in those positions are treated like they lack the same fire and fight.

They completely misunderstand and misrepresent the way the party functions. It's absurd to expect that the people that legislators choose to manage THEIR votes are going to promote much more than what their membership indicates they will support.

So far, both Dem leaders have done a really good job at keeping their respective memberships together on votes; not just key ones, but all votes, so far; managed to keep them together through two shutdowns where they made republicans own their health care cuts and their nazi immigration regime.

Whatever people want to see happen in Congress happens legislatively, not performatively. It only happens with a Democratic majority, and, that only happens by practicing ADDITION (of Dems), not subtraction.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

It's way past the time to defend that guy just because he used to be Klarkashton Sunday #1
When is the next time to vote him out? Melon Sunday #2
2028 DinahMoeHum Sunday #3
Of Course Fetterman Does... he wouldn't Cha Monday #4
I think he needs to... 2naSalit Monday #5
I love Malcolm Kenyatta. Too bad folks from PA could not see that he would have been the better choice tulipsandroses Monday #6
Kenyatta could run again, couldn't he? calimary Monday #16
be careful malcolm there are dems who say we should not be critical of other dems nt msongs Monday #7
specious bigtree Monday #12
I agree about Fetterman. ShazzieB Monday #15
Truth. betsuni Monday #18
Manchin voted with the party 87.9% of time, Fetterman votes with the party 91% of the time. Emile Monday #29
"(M)any of the same people insisted their bullshit in the last presidential election Rob H. Monday #38
did they get what you wanted out of this republican majority? bigtree Monday #39
MY question was, to what specific bullshit are you referring? Rob H. Tuesday #40
I use the term as lightly as I could bigtree Tuesday #43
I don't think of Fetterman as a Dem anymore. ShazzieB Monday #13
I didn't criticize Manchin. He was from W VA. He did what he did to stay afloat. LeftInTX Monday #17
Agreed on all counts. ShazzieB Monday #19
Don't think anyone got in trouble for being critical of Manchin or Sinema standingtall Monday #28
Agree. And we can do better than Fetterman. LeftInTX Monday #32
"functionally a republican" is right! ShazzieB Monday #36
I figure a lotta people say a lotta things. Torchlight Tuesday #42
He has proved one thing timms139 Monday #8
Yeah he's something Figarosmom Monday #9
It's Joe Hudly Monday #10
I know many Reichwing fuckheads who praise Fetterman for "coming to his senses"q Orrex Monday #11
I wish him everything he deserves. niyad Monday #21
He's a DINO. BidenRocks Monday #14
What are the odds for a second, far more serious stroke? niyad Monday #20
Message auto-removed Name removed Monday #22
He CLEARLY underscored the substance in THIS quote: hlthe2b Monday #24
Message auto-removed Name removed Monday #25
Sure... You wouldn't want DEAR LEADER to be criticized after all... hlthe2b Monday #26
Fetterman is malaise Monday #23
;-{) TURNCOAT Goonch Monday #27
I live in Pittsburgh and I voted for Fetterman in 2022, I even donated to his campaign FakeNoose Monday #30
Then Gov Shapiro can replace him! However, I seriously doubt that he will resign. LeftInTX Monday #33
I hope Gov. Shapiro finds a way to convince him to step down FakeNoose Monday #35
From what he done while in office he ran as doc03 Monday #31
Why would Fetterman even support that? I bet numerous GOP senators privately don't support that ballroom. LeftInTX Monday #34
With the upcoming election, we need to be very, very careful Grim Chieftain Monday #37
Message auto-removed Name removed Tuesday #41
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»'You're a mess John Fette...»Reply #39