Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Sympthsical

(11,355 posts)
27. Incrementalists within the system vs. Reformers who think the system is broken
Thu Jul 9, 2026, 11:59 AM
5 hrs ago

It's one of the major problems for me. I consider myself progressive in that FDR level change is required to fix what the incrementalists have more or less stood by and allowed to happen over the past 40 years (with many actively participating in it as they lined their pockets, those wily stock prognosticators).

You don't get to this level of economic decline for the working classes, the harm to unions and the erosion of social safety nets, without allowing it to happen to some degree. Look at California. Now, let's discuss reining in utilities like PG&E, dealing with the housing crisis, and stop cutting social services. Sacramento will laugh you out of the room. That's nice, peasant, but we're making deals over here.

We've seen the influence of corporations grow over the decades, and rather than fight that with every ounce of their being, they figured they'd co-opt them. But they didn't. The corporations co-opted them.

Oh, people still get improvements here and there, but it's truly crumbs in the scheme of things as the looting of the American treasury and the American people continues apace.

But, the two sides generally agree on some basic things. Social liberalism for the most part. The Supreme Court for the most part. It's economics where the division is most profound.

When the system is one step forward, two steps back, I just don't enjoy the "One Step Forward For Life!" people. And when you note it, it's "Oh, so you don't like a step forward? What are you, a regressive?!" It's tiresomely disingenuous. And you know who's usually pro-one step? People who are largely insulated from the next two.

But it's been blowing up in some faces the past ten years. Yes, it has.

Recommendations

4 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

liberals occasionally justaprogressive 7 hrs ago #1
That's my impression. So I guess that makes him part of the "establishment" Walleye 6 hrs ago #11
Historically, by the Progressive Era bucolic_frolic 6 hrs ago #2
Both do both paleotn 6 hrs ago #5
Can't entirely agree or disagree bucolic_frolic 6 hrs ago #7
You couldn't slide piece of paper through the difference paleotn 6 hrs ago #3
Agree. It's lost all meaning. BannonsLiver 5 hrs ago #26
Progressives stand for progress and change Fiendish Thingy 6 hrs ago #4
I'm glad you noted "stand for" progress and change. W_HAMILTON 6 hrs ago #8
Well, I was referring to progressive politicians specifically, not voters Fiendish Thingy 6 hrs ago #14
Yes, it is standing up for one's values. W_HAMILTON 6 hrs ago #19
Like I said, a debateable strategy Fiendish Thingy 5 hrs ago #25
It's your civic duty to vote. It's either or. Walleye 3 hrs ago #43
I agree casting a ballot should be mandatory Fiendish Thingy 3 hrs ago #46
I get the feeling that the purpose of elections, to determine the will of the people, is being buried somehow Walleye 2 hrs ago #51
I'm sure someone will chime in with some intricate delineation... W_HAMILTON 6 hrs ago #6
This is what I think, too. CrispyQ 6 hrs ago #16
I think in this particular election being against Trump is enough Walleye 3 hrs ago #44
Some are hip buzzwords Keepthesoulalive 2 hrs ago #52
lets divide progressives. rampartd 6 hrs ago #9
simple Whip-poor-will 6 hrs ago #10
Liberals are more about individual freedom; progressives want to build new structures muriel_volestrangler 6 hrs ago #12
This Progressive is so far left of left... ZDU 6 hrs ago #13
Thank you to everyone who answered. It's all very interesting. Walleye 6 hrs ago #15
Agree - whether people like it or not we have a two party system in America. walkingman 6 hrs ago #18
The two party system is a huge part of the problem. The Madcap 5 hrs ago #31
I do wish we has a parliamentary system. I also wish we were a democracy instead of a democratic republic walkingman 4 hrs ago #36
Joe Biden managed to get some bipartisan legislation passed Walleye 3 hrs ago #45
And if they don't like the two party system, they can feel free to think of it as 100+ million party system. W_HAMILTON 4 hrs ago #37
The word "Liberal" has numerous meanings and different usages. LeftInTX 5 hrs ago #28
I personally think withholding votes, is a shade of "anarchism" LeftInTX 5 hrs ago #34
There are many people who feel the same way we do politically, but they refuse to participate. I don't know what Walleye 3 hrs ago #47
The way I look at it is this.... walkingman 6 hrs ago #17
I described myself as a proud Democrat Walleye 5 hrs ago #24
I'm a "big tent Democrat" LeftInTX 5 hrs ago #33
Message auto-removed Name removed 6 hrs ago #20
I have always identified myself as a liberal for one very simple reason Peacetrain 6 hrs ago #21
I'm a liberal and proud of it. Raftergirl 6 hrs ago #22
This message was self-deleted by its author Prairie_Seagull 5 hrs ago #23
Incrementalists within the system vs. Reformers who think the system is broken Sympthsical 5 hrs ago #27
Progressives are Liberals Progressive dog 5 hrs ago #29
A sliver. RandySF 5 hrs ago #30
Progressives are more idealistic, less pragmatic... BH liberal 5 hrs ago #32
What is the benefit of this question? We all need each other.... legallyblondeNYC 4 hrs ago #35
Progressives tend to work towards a group goal. haele 4 hrs ago #38
Redefined: progressive (anti-establishment, working class, good) liberal (establishment, elite, not progressive, evil). betsuni 3 hrs ago #39
In recent years, Progressives work for progress, 31j20b3 3 hrs ago #40
They used to be called blue dog Democrats and were mostly southern. Raftergirl 3 hrs ago #48
Yes, I was just going to remark on that. In Delaware we had a very liberal Republican governor. But those days are gone Walleye 2 hrs ago #50
Lincoln Chaffee was another one. He eventually left the R party and became a D. Raftergirl 2 hrs ago #53
So did the governor I mentioned. Governor Peterson. Walleye 2 hrs ago #54
Liberals support liberty. Progressives support progress. meadowlander 3 hrs ago #41
Imo, a progressive is someone who is afraid of the word liberal. ananda 3 hrs ago #42
That is my general impression Walleye 2 hrs ago #49
there is no difference mike_c 2 hrs ago #55
I don't think there is an equivalent in the Republican party Walleye 2 hrs ago #56
Liberals are center-left and progressives are left many a good man 54 min ago #57
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»What is the difference be...»Reply #27