Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ancianita

(43,390 posts)
4. Big Nope. Infallibility refers to statements made Ex Cathedra. NO pope has ever spoken ex cathedra to declare slavery
Mon May 25, 2026, 03:38 PM
Yesterday

a morally acceptable practice.

The doctrine of ex cathedra (papal infallibility) is invoked when the pope speaks definitively on matters of faith and morals for the entire Church. No papal statement endorsing or legitimizing slavery has ever met the strict theological criteria required for this classification.

Other popes explicitly opposed the enslavement of specific groups early on. Pope Eugene IV issued the papal bull Sicut Dudum in 1435 condemning the enslavement of newly converted Indigenous people in the Canary Islands, and Pope Paul III issued Sublimis Deus in 1537 forbidding the enslavement of all indigenous peoples in the Americas.

In 1839, Pope Gregory XVI officially condemned the trans-Atlantic slave trade in his bull In Supremo Apostolatus. Later, the Church formally declared chattel slavery — based on race or treating human beings as property — to be a grave violation of human dignity.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Pope Leo is going to make a major impact, given he is not afraid to speak truth... hlthe2b Yesterday #1
Love this man Clouds Passing Yesterday #2
Having to apologize for a centuries-long oopsie kind of puts a big crack in that whole "papal infallibility" thing. LudwigPastorius Yesterday #3
Big Nope. Infallibility refers to statements made Ex Cathedra. NO pope has ever spoken ex cathedra to declare slavery ancianita Yesterday #4
So, popes (say Nick V, for instance) can be fallible, as long as their directives aren't "official". LudwigPastorius 15 hrs ago #6
They are human and can err. But almost all of the 267 pope's in Jesus's 2,000 year old church hold to the Gospel ancianita 7 hrs ago #9
It's a shame that that this gesture has gotten lost and drowned out in all the absurd news. BumRushDaShow 22 hrs ago #5
Well, not totally drowned out. It stayed as the digital front page headline of the New York Times yesterday. ancianita 7 hrs ago #7
Not that many still have a NYT sub BumRushDaShow 7 hrs ago #8
Around 15 million digital subscribers by the end of next year. ancianita 6 hrs ago #10
But as you might have noticed BumRushDaShow 6 hrs ago #11
Of course the audience might include all who are neutral, or of all other faiths. The encyclical is to people of ancianita 5 hrs ago #12
I agree on the intent and appreciate Pope Leo going farther than even Francis on advocacy BumRushDaShow 5 hrs ago #13
Well, he's starting from a divine place that moves toward peace on Earth. Where and what ancianita 3 hrs ago #15
There will always be the battle BumRushDaShow 3 hrs ago #16
Yes, agree. You're foundational in posting the news; that said, the battle isn't always what it's reported to be. ancianita 3 hrs ago #17
This afternoon and yesterday was such an example of the pendulum swings BumRushDaShow 2 hrs ago #18
Absolutely important battles to cover! ancianita 1 hr ago #19
Now do apologizing for forcing women to give birth at the cost of their own lives. 50 Shades Of Blue 4 hrs ago #14
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Pope Leo XIV makes histor...»Reply #4