There are no public records or videos of Melania Trump conducting a full interview, giving a speech, or engaging in a sustained, unscripted technical conversation in French, German, or Italian.
Verified Languages: It is undisputed that she is fluent in Slovenian (her native tongue) and English (somewhat). However, she speaks English with a heavy accent, which some critics conflate with a lack of proficiency.
The 2017 Paris Visit: During her July 2017 visit to Necker Hospital in Paris. While she greeted children with "Bonjour" and "Ça va?", she reportedly reverted to English for the remainder of the interaction. Observers noted that Brigitte Macron, who is fluent in English, often served as the primary bridge in their conversations.
The Italian "Proof": Supporters often point to a 2017 visit to a children's hospital in Rome where she spoke Italian to a young patient. While she was filmed saying a few phrases ("Ciao," "Come stai?"
, linguists and critics argue that these were basic greetings and do not necessarily demonstrate the high-level "fluency" required for complex diplomacy.
Edit history
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
= new reply since forum marked as read