Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

justaprogressive

(6,861 posts)
20. This one!
Sun Dec 7, 2025, 02:31 PM
Dec 2025




Italian Butter Cookies

Buttery and creamy, with hints of vanilla and almond,
these melt in your mouth morsels are indisputably delicious!

PREP: 20 Minutes
BAKE: 8 Minutes
YIELD: Depends on the cookie press disc used

INGREDIENTS


1 cup unsalted butter
3/4 cup granulated sugar
1 extra large egg
*1 teaspoon almond extract
*1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
Chocolate chips
Sprinkling sugars
Food colors, for tinting, if desired

*Ed. These are large huge quantities!

In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with a paddle
attachment, cream the butter and sugar on medium for five
minutes, until light and fluffy. Scrape down the sides of the
bowl, and with the mixer on low, add the egg, and then the
two extracts.

Sift the flour and the salt together. With the mixer on
low, add the flour mixture to the butter mixture slowly,
scraping down the sides of the bowl several times, until a
soft dough forms.

If you wish to divide the dough and use tints, you may do
so at this point. Fit a cookie press with your desired tip, and
with one chocolate chip pressed into the center. The dough
press is best when slightly chilled but not hard. If using
sprinkling sugars, decorate at will. Press the cookies about
two inches apart onto the parchment lined sheets and chill
the cookies for fifteen minutes.

Preheat the oven to 375° F. Place one oven rack in the center
of the oven. Bake the cookies one tray at a time in the center
of the oven for eight minutes, rotating the baking sheet
halfway through. Watch the cookies closely; they should
not brown but remain pale and soft.

Remove the baking sheets to wire cooling racks and cool
for ten minutes; remove the cookies to cooling racks to cool
completely. Store the cookies in the refrigerator in a very
airtight container between layers of waxed paper. Allow the
cookies to come to room temperature before serving

NOTES:

Butter cookies are very delicate; they absorb strong aromas.
When baking, I make sure the ovenis very clean. When
cooling the cookies, I make sure there is nothing else out in the
kitchen. I only store in very clean plastic containers, or fresh
new resealable bags. I don’t usually tint my cookies; I leave
them plain. When using a cookie press with a tip, I prefer to
use the floret or the daisy for a classic look.

From "The Cookie King"
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/29996003-the-cookie-king

Recommendations

4 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I haven't tried that, but would like to. pandr32 Dec 2025 #1
I love your cookie selections, Kolachy are Eastern European cookies, made with a cream cheese dough. Roll it out into debm55 Dec 2025 #3
Sounds amazing! pandr32 Dec 2025 #25
When I was a young girl my Baba made them-I watched her, There was no recipe she made them from. I asked. Every year I debm55 Dec 2025 #26
I agree with the Kolachy exept with cherries in them. OLDMDDEM Dec 2025 #79
Thank you OLDMDDEM. That sounds great. debm55 Dec 2025 #82
Gingerbread cookies anciano Dec 2025 #2
Thank you very much for sharing with us, anciano. debm55 Dec 2025 #4
I can't remember what they're called, boonecreek Dec 2025 #5
I remember those. Thank you for sharing boonecreek. I think we just called them Hershey Kiss cookies. I don't know the debm55 Dec 2025 #10
Hersey peanut butter blooms. sinkingfeeling Dec 2025 #11
Thank you for the name, sinkingfeeling.for the name. debm55 Dec 2025 #16
I used to make shortbread cookies as a kid at christmas. applegrove Dec 2025 #6
Thank you very much applegrove. I loved making those decorated sugar cookies.Oh and those silver balls and sprinkles debm55 Dec 2025 #18
We used to always get one of those round tins House of Roberts Dec 2025 #7
Thank you very much, House of Roberts. I remember them --they came in a blue tin. Loved them debm55 Dec 2025 #19
Brandy snaps chowmama Dec 2025 #8
OH wow. Thank you very much for sharing with us, chowmama. They sound delicious. debm55 Dec 2025 #21
A Pennsylvania Dutch delicacy, Sugar Cakes Freddie Dec 2025 #9
Thank you very much Freddie for sharing that with us. We have a Giant Eagle here in SW PA but no Giant. I am going to debm55 Dec 2025 #22
Mexican hot chocolate cookies and peppermint candy cane cookies. sinkingfeeling Dec 2025 #12
Thank you very much for sharing with us, sinkingfeeling. I used to make the pepperment candy cane cookies. I have never debm55 Dec 2025 #23
I have several buzzycrumbhunger Dec 2025 #13
Thank you very much for your selections buzzycrumbhunger. I have made the Russian tea cakes. Agree with the powdered debm55 Dec 2025 #15
Frosted sugar cookies, decorated and sprinkled with sprinkles. Polly Hennessey Dec 2025 #14
Good for you Polly Hennessey. I love your selections. debm55 Dec 2025 #17
This one! justaprogressive Dec 2025 #20
Oh my they look great. and I bet they taste wonderful. Thank you so much for sharing, justaprogressive. Are you trained debm55 Dec 2025 #24
worked justaprogressive Dec 2025 #30
Now we know. Your love of cooking shines through. Polly Hennessey Dec 2025 #32
You are a fantastic and talented person, justaprogressive. debm55 Dec 2025 #36
...💙 justaprogressive Dec 2025 #68
Thanks for photo and recipe. beveeheart Dec 2025 #63
They sure look good😀 malaise Dec 2025 #70
Every cookie deb is my favorite. Duncanpup Dec 2025 #27
HAHHAHHAHHAHAH. Thank you for sharing your selections,Duncanpup HAHAHHHAHHAHHAH debm55 Dec 2025 #35
My mom made wonderful toll house cookies. They were my favorite. Borogove Dec 2025 #28
Thank you very much Borogove. I like them fresh out of the oven with a cold glass of milk May the memories of your mom debm55 Dec 2025 #47
Vanilla bean cookies bfoxmatt Dec 2025 #29
HAHHHAHAHA. Thank you very much, bfoxmatt. Your cookies sound so delicious with over the top taste. Thank you for debm55 Dec 2025 #34
Two of my favorites I still make each year. Big Blue Marble Dec 2025 #31
Thank you very much, Big Blue Marble . Your two selections sound wonderful. Enjoy my friend. debm55 Dec 2025 #33
Overwhelmed much? Dear_Prudence Dec 2025 #37
thank you very much. Dear_Prudence. I remember the slice and bake cookies. My very young son enjoyed watching me make debm55 Dec 2025 #39
Dear_Prudence, Diamond_Dog Dec 2025 #65
Wow! Dear_Prudence Dec 2025 #69
Buckeyes CanonRay Dec 2025 #38
Thank you very much CanonRay. Wonderful cookie. They are so good. Enjoy and give Mrs. Canon a big kiss for making them debm55 Dec 2025 #46
Biscochitos from New Mexico! Loisita123 Dec 2025 #40
I use powdered sugar on my Russian tea cakes and I agree with you Loisita123.--it makes a mess. I love debm55 Dec 2025 #45
Snickerdoodles Onthefly Dec 2025 #41
Thank you very much Onthefly. You are so right --easy to make and a wonderful cookie to eat. Enjoy. debm55 Dec 2025 #43
Hard to find, but Delicious! beemerphill Dec 2025 #42
Thank you very much beemerphill for the suggestion. The name sounds familiar. I think I had one-fantastic, but never debm55 Dec 2025 #44
Walkers Shortbread malaise Dec 2025 #48
Thank you so much for sharing with us. malaise. Scottish shortbread. I bet it is good. Thank you debm55 Dec 2025 #49
The more recent one with chocolate chips malaise Dec 2025 #50
I am going to look into that. Thank you very much. debm55 Dec 2025 #59
Here malaise Dec 2025 #62
Thank you very much, malaise. I will see if they have the next time I go to the store. debm55 Dec 2025 #72
The ginger ones are also very good. mwmisses4289 Dec 2025 #66
Yes indeed malaise Dec 2025 #67
White Chocolate Macadamia Cookies Emile Dec 2025 #51
Wow. that sounds great. Thank you very much Emile. for sharing with us. debm55 Dec 2025 #55
jelly-topped sugar cookies Eugene Dec 2025 #52
I love those. Thank you so much, Eugene, for sharing those delights with us. Enjoy. debm55 Dec 2025 #58
Date bars. Sneederbunk Dec 2025 #53
YUMMY! Thank you very much Sneederbunk for sharing with us. They sound great. Enjoy. debm55 Dec 2025 #54
My mom made a date bar with beveeheart Dec 2025 #64
Thank you very much beceeheart for sharing. They sound delicious. debm55 Dec 2025 #75
I like them all! Diamond_Dog Dec 2025 #56
Thank you very much, Check you justaprogressive's post on Sunday cookies. debm55 Dec 2025 #60
Raspberry Thumprint cookies Endlessmike56 Dec 2025 #57
thank you very much Endlessmike56. and may the memories of your mom be a blessing to you. debm55 Dec 2025 #61
Same here! WestMichRad Dec 2025 #71
I guess the sugar cookies with the colored crunchy sprinkes covering them.... electric_blue68 Dec 2025 #73
Thank you very much, electric_blue68 Those cookies are great any time of the year. debm55 Dec 2025 #76
I think someone mentioned churning butter? electric_blue68 Dec 2025 #74
Yes, I used to have my class take heavy whipping cream. I would add a little sugar and salt. I then put in a closed debm55 Dec 2025 #77
Ha! Interesting! electric_blue68 Dec 2025 #78
The key is heavy whipping cream. debm55 Dec 2025 #80
Got it! electric_blue68 Dec 2025 #81
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»What is/are your favorite...»Reply #20