Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Denzil_DC

(8,061 posts)
15. I think you'll know me well enough by now to know that I shy away from making electoral predictions!
Fri Apr 21, 2017, 06:25 AM
Apr 2017

The key question on all pundits' lips is whether the SNP can match the 56 out of 59 MPs it won in the last election, or even surpass it. Talk about a high bar, and possibly a hiding to nothing! Given the massive swings to the SNP in the last Westminster election, we could see some wacky stats on election night. The chances are that any result will be portrayed by the media as "a blow to Sturgeon/the SNP".

The election here's shaping up to be framed as independence versus (UK) unionism, complicated to some extent by the dynamics of Brexit.

The Tories under Ruth Davidson, Labour and the Lib Dems have been hammering this even during the run-up to the local government elections. As for Davidson herself - for a while a media darling, with the hype extending to seeing a prominent party role for her at UK level - the shine has been coming off quickly among all but hardline unionists. She made a national name for herself as an eloquent Remainer (and a racy speaker who often titillated old Tories) in the Brexit referendum. Now she's a firm backer of May's agenda, down to the revolting "rape clause", for which she was pilloried from all quarters at Holyrood the other day. So much for principle.

Labour are continuing to maunder on under Kezia Dugdale, with weak, unclear and vacillating policy positions beyond the usual "SNP bad" and pro-Unionism. It's to be hoped this will be Dugdale's last election, as it's just getting embarrassing now, even for her political opponents.

One interesting development is that the Scottish Greens' co-convenor, Patrick Harvey, has announced that they won't be standing a candidate in Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale, the constituency narrowly held in the last election by Scotland's sole Tory MP David Mundell, who was appointed Secretary of State for Scotland by default, and has proven a Mayite lackey to the extreme. This will give the SNP a clearer run at the seat, and Mundell's an obvious main target for them.

Pro-Union/anti-SNP tactical voting will make the results very difficult to poll and predict, but there are very few constituencies where there's a clear runner-up to the SNP to serve as a focus for such votes. The Tories were strongly flattered by the D'Hondt PR system in the last Scottish parliamentary elections, surpassing Labour as the second largest party at Holyrood. They won't have that advantage this time.

It's even more a crunch election here than in the rest of the UK. Not only does the likely course to a second indyref hinge on it, with Brexit a key focus, but so does the raft of powers devolved to Holyrood - the Great Repeal Bill and its aftermath would, if things go as planned, allow the Tories to rewrite the UK's whole constitutional settlement with little or no parliamentary scrutiny, including the devolved assemblies and the Scottish Parliament. It's easy to imagine that they'd use the opportunity to strip away Holyrood's influence and power. Whether they'd go so far as to abolish Holyrood is up for question. I guess it depends how big a fight they're willing to pick.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Thanks for these, T_i_B Ghost Dog Apr 2015 #1
Some Northern Ireland links T_i_B Apr 2015 #2
"a website that acts as an effective deterrent to anyone who doesn't speak fluent Welsh" Denzil_DC Apr 2015 #3
That's even worse then the loaded questions on the front of Labour's website T_i_B Apr 2015 #4
You're seeing it from the perspective of someone who doesn't live in Wales. Denzil_DC Apr 2015 #5
You are wrong T_i_B Apr 2015 #11
"Now you may consider those people to be 'inpure' or even traitors Denzil_DC Apr 2015 #13
I actually like the leaders of these parties better than any of the mainstream Westminster ones LeftishBrit Apr 2015 #6
Though, technically, she'll stay a Holyrood leader, since she's not standing for Westminster muriel_volestrangler Apr 2015 #7
Sturgeon's indicated clearly that she would be negotiating for the SNP after the election. Denzil_DC Apr 2015 #8
Yes - it will be interesting to see how this plays out. LeftishBrit Apr 2015 #12
I think the SNP's strength is that it can look like the LDP, but without the massive baggage MisterP Apr 2015 #9
The fight for the "real left" with Scottish Labour is something Labour has long abandoned. Denzil_DC Apr 2015 #10
2017 General election kick T_i_B Apr 2017 #14
I think you'll know me well enough by now to know that I shy away from making electoral predictions! Denzil_DC Apr 2017 #15
Well, if you live in Scotland... T_i_B Apr 2017 #16
Linton Crosbie demonized Sturgeon and the SNP in the last UK election. Denzil_DC Apr 2017 #17
In the aftermath of the 2015 election.... T_i_B Apr 2017 #18
2019 General election kick T_i_B Oct 2019 #19
Like everywhere else in the UK, it's tough to call what may happen in this election. Denzil_DC Nov 2019 #20
Post removed Post removed Sep 2020 #21
How did a 'Post removed' suddenly get on a thread that started in 2015? LeftishBrit Sep 2020 #22
Didn't see it. Denzil_DC Sep 2020 #23
Bingo. Rhiannon12866 Sep 2020 #25
You know what kinds of posts show up on really old threads Rhiannon12866 Sep 2020 #24
You're right - I have some MIRT experience! LeftishBrit Sep 2020 #26
2024 general election kick T_i_B May 2024 #27
Latest Discussions»Region Forums»United Kingdom»UK Parties: The SNP &...»Reply #15