Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Israel/Palestine
In reply to the discussion: How Nazi Propaganda and the Muslim Brotherhood Led to the 1948 Israel-Arab War [View all]Little Tich
(6,171 posts)60. Perhaps I'm reading the article differently.
The article deals with the supposed causes for the civil war in Palestine just as much as it deals with the war between Israel and the Arab states:
The Aftershock of the Nazi War against the Jews, 194748: Could War in the Middle East Have Been Prevented?
Source: Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, by Dr. Matthias Küntzel, March 31, 2016
(snip)
Conclusion
This article has shown that the impact of antisemitism and the role of al-Husseini linked the Nazi war against the Jews with that of 1947/48. Therefore, Hillel Cohen is correct in claiming that there can be little doubt that the Muftis inflexible position and refusal to accept any partition proposal were the major reasons for the outbreak of war in 1948.74 However, the Mufti might have ended his career in 1945, had the Western powers not allowed him to escape justice and had the Arabs not protected him out of opportunism. The cowardice of important figures paved the way for one of the most fateful turning points in twentieth-century history: the war of the Arab armies against the fledgling state of Israel.
This war was not inevitable. It happened because Nazi antisemitic anti-Zionist propaganda continued to dominate the political culture of the Arab world after the defeat of Germany, thus preventing any viable challenge to the antisemitic policies of the Mufti and the Muslim Brotherhood. Therefore, the war of 1947/48 appears as an aftershock of the Nazi war against the Jews. The Middle East has never recovered from this watershed. To this day, Palestinian leaders continue to refuse to recognize the Jewish state. At present, Bernard Lewis question, What went wrong? recurs more persistently than ever before. To answer this question, one cannot overlook the impact of the Nazis antisemitic propaganda and the inability of the key Arab actors to distance themselves from it.
This article has shown that the impact of antisemitism and the role of al-Husseini linked the Nazi war against the Jews with that of 1947/48. Therefore, Hillel Cohen is correct in claiming that there can be little doubt that the Muftis inflexible position and refusal to accept any partition proposal were the major reasons for the outbreak of war in 1948.74 However, the Mufti might have ended his career in 1945, had the Western powers not allowed him to escape justice and had the Arabs not protected him out of opportunism. The cowardice of important figures paved the way for one of the most fateful turning points in twentieth-century history: the war of the Arab armies against the fledgling state of Israel.
This war was not inevitable. It happened because Nazi antisemitic anti-Zionist propaganda continued to dominate the political culture of the Arab world after the defeat of Germany, thus preventing any viable challenge to the antisemitic policies of the Mufti and the Muslim Brotherhood. Therefore, the war of 1947/48 appears as an aftershock of the Nazi war against the Jews. The Middle East has never recovered from this watershed. To this day, Palestinian leaders continue to refuse to recognize the Jewish state. At present, Bernard Lewis question, What went wrong? recurs more persistently than ever before. To answer this question, one cannot overlook the impact of the Nazis antisemitic propaganda and the inability of the key Arab actors to distance themselves from it.
Read more: http://jcpa.org/article/aftershock-nazi-war-jews-1947-1948-could-war-middle-east-prevented/
I actually want to bury this revisionist turd ASAP, so I'll just give a last comment on it: This recent neocon smear that the the Palestinians and Arabs were all nazis doesn't add up. This is new information, and if it was true, it would've been discovered by Benny Morris and the other new Israeli historians already - but they don't make this connection at all.
I'll stick with the new Israeli historians, they're serious scholars and don't just make things up, like Dr. Matthias Küntzel does.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
68 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
How Nazi Propaganda and the Muslim Brotherhood Led to the 1948 Israel-Arab War [View all]
aranthus
Apr 2016
OP
He's a hack & fraud with zero credibility. He has admitted he doesn't deal in facts. n/t
shira
Apr 2016
#32
Another "All Palestinians are responsible for the shit the Grand Mufti did" thread.
Ken Burch
Apr 2016
#4
So this should be surpressed because you've decided the motive for posting it ?
King_David
Apr 2016
#9
The problem in the Mideast is that *everyone* has both historical, and refreshed, excuses
villager
Apr 2016
#27
Thanks, Ken. I've given up hope, actually, that either side will stop "Otherizing" their "enemies."
villager
Apr 2016
#35
The fear(soon realized) of mass dispossession and exile were one of the major reasons
Ken Burch
Apr 2016
#48
There's a vocal minority of those here on DU that blame Israel for everything.
King_David
Apr 2016
#13
I don't approve of their tactics, but what they were offered in '48 was too small to be a real state
Ken Burch
Apr 2016
#22
The '47 partition plan was more a state than what the Palestinians are asking for today....
shira
Apr 2016
#24
Israel haters don't like being reminded that their cause is linked to Nazi Jew hatred. n/t
shira
Apr 2016
#40
The Arab Palestinians did not have a military so how were they able to launch attacks?
Tony_FLADEM
Apr 2016
#64