Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Israel/Palestine
In reply to the discussion: Using stolen water to irrigate stolen land [View all]Israeli
(4,306 posts)24. Israel Incapable of Telling Truth About Water It Steals From Palestinians
Water is the only issue in which Israel (still) finds it difficult to defend its discriminatory, oppressive and destructive policy with pretexts of security and God.
Amira Hass
Jun 22, 2016
Israeli spokespeople have three answers ready to pull out when they respond to questions on the water shortage in West Bank Palestinian towns which stands out starkly compared to the hydrological smugness of the settlements: 1) The Palestinian water system is old, so it suffers from water loss; 2) the Palestinians steal water from each other, and from the Israelis; and 3) in general, Israel has in its great generosity doubled the amount of water it supplies to the Palestinians, compared to what was called for in the Oslo Accords.
Supplies, the spokespeople will write in their responses. They will never say Israel sells the Palestinians 64 million cubic meters of water a year instead of the 31 million cubic meters agreed to in the Oslo Accords. Accords that were signed in 1994, and that were supposed to come to an end in 1999. They will not say that Israel sells the Palestinians water that it first stole from them.
Bravo for the demagogy. Bravo for the one-eighth portion of truth in the answer. Water is the only issue in which Israel (still) finds it difficult to defend its discriminatory, oppressive and destructive policy with pretexts of security and God. That is why it must blur and distort this basic fact: Israel controls the water sources. And being in control, it imposes a quota on the amount of water the Palestinians are allowed to produce and consume. On average, the Palestinians consume 73 liters per person per day. Below the recommended minimum. Israelis consume a daily 180 liters on average, and there are those who say even more. And here, unlike there, you will not find thousands who consume 20 liters a day. In the summer.
read more: http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.726350
Amira Hass
Jun 22, 2016
Israeli spokespeople have three answers ready to pull out when they respond to questions on the water shortage in West Bank Palestinian towns which stands out starkly compared to the hydrological smugness of the settlements: 1) The Palestinian water system is old, so it suffers from water loss; 2) the Palestinians steal water from each other, and from the Israelis; and 3) in general, Israel has in its great generosity doubled the amount of water it supplies to the Palestinians, compared to what was called for in the Oslo Accords.
Supplies, the spokespeople will write in their responses. They will never say Israel sells the Palestinians 64 million cubic meters of water a year instead of the 31 million cubic meters agreed to in the Oslo Accords. Accords that were signed in 1994, and that were supposed to come to an end in 1999. They will not say that Israel sells the Palestinians water that it first stole from them.
Bravo for the demagogy. Bravo for the one-eighth portion of truth in the answer. Water is the only issue in which Israel (still) finds it difficult to defend its discriminatory, oppressive and destructive policy with pretexts of security and God. That is why it must blur and distort this basic fact: Israel controls the water sources. And being in control, it imposes a quota on the amount of water the Palestinians are allowed to produce and consume. On average, the Palestinians consume 73 liters per person per day. Below the recommended minimum. Israelis consume a daily 180 liters on average, and there are those who say even more. And here, unlike there, you will not find thousands who consume 20 liters a day. In the summer.
read more: http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.726350
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
28 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
"Do ya wanna tell me a story bout' trollops and plug tails? Please?" "Back home, Puff-guts would
Little Tich
Jul 2016
#3
For me, it's not logical that the UN, the World Bank, Amnesty, the French Parliament and B'tselem
Little Tich
Jul 2016
#5
You know they've lied before WRT denying Hamas human shields & child militants....
shira
Jul 2016
#6
Sometimes the truth has to fudged a little bit to fit with the Zionist narrative.
Little Tich
Jul 2016
#9
Here's just one example of B'tselem lying about civilian casualties from Cast Lead 2009
shira
Jul 2016
#11
So when different neutral organizations reach the same conclusion about the casualties independently
Little Tich
Jul 2016
#16
Those "different neutral" sources all got their info. from Hamas' Gaza Health Ministry
shira
Jul 2016
#18
It wasn't 69-75%. That was a lie Hamas admitted when they agreed w/ the IDF numbers....
shira
Jul 2016
#21
You trust Hamas' figures b/c that's where the UN, B'tselem, HRW got their numbers
shira
Jul 2016
#26
The Human rights NGOs are using available evidence, including figures from Hamas.
Little Tich
Jul 2016
#27
So basically, there aren't ANY groups who oppose what Netanyahu and Bennett do in the West Bank
Ken Burch
Jul 2016
#12
We're talking B'tselem here & you don't have a problem with their lies & incitement to hate....
shira
Jul 2016
#13
They actually aren't proven liars. It's just that the Israeli right refuses to accept
Ken Burch
Jul 2016
#17