Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Beastly Boy

(11,147 posts)
15. I don't see much practicality expressed in the article.
Sun Feb 19, 2023, 04:37 PM
Feb 2023

The author fails to make his point. While his call to abandon the two state solution is categorical, the argument for it is weak. It is certainly not supported by the study he is quoting from.

For example, his conclusion that "It is clear that the overwhelming fixation of the majority of Arabs...is for the disappearance of Israel" does not hold water. He claims, citing the study, that it is based on "the facts on the ground", but in fact, it's quite the contrary: the study shows between 30 and 35% support for one non-democratic state, both among the Palestinians and the Israelis. This alone puts the author's grasp of the facts on the ground in question. And there are several similar examples that contradict the author's conclusion.

Other than calling for drastic societal changes, without enumerating them or proposing any plans to achieve them, there is nothing in the article that offers an alternative to the two state solution. The article is clear about the failure of what you call "old idealistic solutions", but it doesn't offer anything resembling new non-idealistic ones.

A curious perspective Beastly Boy Feb 2023 #1
Is he wrong though? Mosby Feb 2023 #2
He is wrong to say the two state solution is dead, or that Beastly Boy Feb 2023 #3
As long as he is alive sabbat hunter Feb 2023 #5
Ive never heard of Israeli Feb 2023 #9
A curious choice of an article to begin with. Beastly Boy Feb 2023 #11
It's not exactly news that most Palestinians Mosby Feb 2023 #14
I don't see much practicality expressed in the article. Beastly Boy Feb 2023 #15
If the two state solution is dead sabbat hunter Feb 2023 #4
That's obviously not going to happen. Mosby Feb 2023 #6
in a one state sabbat hunter Feb 2023 #7
I have a very hard time staying positive. Mosby Feb 2023 #8
You dont have a clue Israeli Feb 2023 #12
I'm pretty familiar with the Israeli political system Mosby Feb 2023 #13
I wasnt referring to our politics Israeli Feb 2023 #17
The really sad part is sabbat hunter Feb 2023 #19
nor will you Israeli Feb 2023 #20
What has happened sabbat hunter Feb 2023 #21
It really is curious Mosby Feb 2023 #23
This message was self-deleted by its author sabbat hunter Feb 2023 #22
Dream on ...nt. Israeli Feb 2023 #10
I do not sabbat hunter Feb 2023 #16
Apologies Israeli Feb 2023 #18
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Israel/Palestine»This message was self-del...»Reply #15