Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

William Seger

(11,297 posts)
32. The thermite hypothesis was invented by Steven Jones...
Thu Dec 10, 2015, 12:30 PM
Dec 2015

... simply because a demolition by magic silent explosives is so obviously idiotic, not because there is shred of credible evidence for it. Then Jones and Harrit made a complete laughing stock of "truth movement science" with their thermitic paint chip nonsense, since the only thing they proved was that having a PhD doesn't make you a competent scientist. Unfortunately, using thermite for a controlled demolition is just another imaginary technology, perhaps not as idiotic as magic silent explosives but ridiculously implausible and completely unsubstantiated nonetheless. Here's a clue: Gage still talks about explosives when he wants to claim that's the only explanation for the "sudden" onset of collapse and the hurling of beams hundreds of feet, but then switches to thermite when someone points out that magical silent explosives don't exist. When someone points out how improbable it is that you could get thermite to melt through all those columns at the same time (and that he just claimed explosives were the only explanation), he switches to some sort of hybrid hypothesis of both thermite and explosives (both of which must have been oddly fireproof). Since neither one makes any sense whatsoever and neither is supported by any credible evidence, Gage thinks maybe it was both! Gage is the poster boy for "truth movement" self delusion, yet we are continually insulted by the assertion that people who buy his bullshit are possessed with superior reasoning powers and intellectual courage, and that anyone who doesn't fall for it must be afraid of the "truth" or must be in on the cover-up.

> First, any thermate used merely crackles and sizzles.

No, thermite also creates very intense light and huge white clouds of aluminum oxide, neither of which were observed, and more importantly it leaves rather obvious amounts of slag, which was also not observed. In fact, there was no evidence at all of either explosives or thermite found in the debris pile, so conspiracy theorists just assume all the people involved with the cleanup must have been in on the cover-up. In the world of conspiracism, any evidence that supports the "official story" must have have been faked and any evidence that would definitively prove a conspiracy must have been covered up. This is how conspiracy theorists, in attempting to rationalize promoting their paranoid delusions to be religious "truth," work themselves into a position where they are forced to abandon evidence-based reasoning completely and to continually add more and more people to the conspiracy. That's what makes conspiracism an especially pernicious form of bullshit: it slowly robs its victims of the ability to deal with reality on a rational basis. I think there's a reason you can't see this...

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

thanks for posting. looking forward to it. Check this video... wildbilln864 Nov 2015 #1
Sounds like the Prof is on top of things. JohnyCanuck Nov 2015 #2
k&r nationalize the fed Nov 2015 #3
I wonder how whitefordmd Nov 2015 #4
you are... wildbilln864 Nov 2015 #5
Thanks for the typo correction whitefordmd Nov 2015 #6
that depend upon wildbilln864 Nov 2015 #7
You're avoiding the issue.... whitefordmd Nov 2015 #11
No. They're not "my guys". wildbilln864 Nov 2015 #13
Look at the damned NIST report: dougolat Dec 2015 #28
"good enough" for what purpose? William Seger Dec 2015 #29
There you go again with that 'silent explosives' canard. dougolat Dec 2015 #30
The thermite hypothesis was invented by Steven Jones... William Seger Dec 2015 #32
To what NIST report are you referring? whitefordmd Dec 2015 #31
The study is already biased before it begins William Seger Nov 2015 #8
unike NIST wildbilln864 Nov 2015 #9
If the study shows that fire could have destroyed WTC7 William Seger Nov 2015 #10
I accept that now! wildbilln864 Nov 2015 #12
Very interesting William Seger Dec 2015 #14
nope! wildbilln864 Dec 2015 #16
Watch THIS video William Seger Dec 2015 #17
do you realize wildbilln864 Dec 2015 #18
And if they needed magical silent explosives to do that William Seger Dec 2015 #19
Silent demolitions? whitefordmd Dec 2015 #20
I doubt it would be silent but wildbilln864 Dec 2015 #22
Ok not silent, but concealed. whitefordmd Dec 2015 #24
the demos were not wildbilln864 Dec 2015 #25
I think I am getting it whitefordmd Dec 2015 #26
You Do Realize That Physics Do Not Support Such Nonsense ProfessorGAC Dec 2015 #33
well that's obvious bullshit! wildbilln864 Dec 2015 #34
Just curious whitefordmd Dec 2015 #15
NIST described some of the "fiddling" they did William Seger Dec 2015 #21
well that's more nonsense but wildbilln864 Dec 2015 #23
Why is that nonsense? whitefordmd Dec 2015 #27
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Creative Speculation»Forensic engineer/univers...»Reply #32