"... to explain the thousands of tiny human bone fragments scattered about."
If I were to say, "your Gumshoe is an idiot," that would not really be a "logical" conclusion because there could be other reasons why he might say something so asinine. It could be that he just doesn't understand what "logical" means, or perhaps he thinks you'll buy that nonsense because you're not very logical, or he might even be intentionally (rather than accidentally) demonstrating Poe's Law.
But we don't need to figure out his intentions to examine his "logic." He's saying that since the following events couldn't possibly explain "thousands of tiny human bone fragments scattered about," then "the only logical explanation" is massive quantities of magical silent explosives:
Edit history
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
= new reply since forum marked as read