Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

aikoaiko

(34,202 posts)
103. And also consider this -- well-reguluated as an adj modifies militia and not the people.
Tue Nov 17, 2015, 02:53 PM
Nov 2015

Regardless of its meaning, its not about controlling the people's right to keep and bear arms from which a well-regulated militia can be drawn. But see OED entries below; #2 addresses regulated troops.

regulated, adj.

1. Properly controlled, governed, or directed; subject to guidance or regulations. Also: adjusted in response to, or in order to conform to, a principle, standard, set of circumstances, etc.
Freq. with modifying word, as badly-, best-, ill-, well-regulated, etc.

1615 T. Tuke Christians Looking Glasse 70 Hee that loues God truely, and with a well regulated loue will loue God, chiefly for God himselfe.
a1631 J. Donne Serm. (1957) III. 243 How Matrimonially soever such persons as have maried themselves may pretend to love,..yet..all that life is but a regulated Adultery.
1697 J. Woodward Acct. Relig. Societies London in Earnest Admon. Young Persons 142 Those regulated Societies, which are now..conspicuous among us for many good Works.
a1704 T. Brown Ess. Satire Ancients in Wks. (1730) I. 16 These [verses]..had regulated forms, that is regular dances and musick.
1731 tr. Winter Evening Tales xvi. 238 Even in the best regulated families some petty Quarrels will arise.
1766 Compl. Farmer at Surveying, Then may you measure all the whole chains by your regulated chain.
1828 J. M. Spearman Brit. Gunner 336 They are fired with a regulated charge of powder and shot.
1838 Jrnl. Statist. Soc. London 1 358 Many [schools]..are close, filthy, ill-regulated, and the teachers utterly unqualified for either teaching or keeping the children in order.
1897 T. C. Allbutt et al. Syst. Med. IV. 621 Regulated exercises, such as the gentle climbing, especially in mountain districts, known as the terrain cure.
1946 G. Wilson Fidelity Folks 54 He stoutly maintained that a regulated open saloon was to be preferred to the evils of moonshining and boot-legging.
1961 Econ. Bot. 15 357 Contact between the refrigerated plates and packaged product is maintained under regulated pressure.
2008 Daily Mail (Nexis) 8 Oct. 91 We need only to look at banking to see what can happen in a badly regulated industry.


†2. Of troops, an army, etc.: properly organized; formally constituted into a professional body. Also fig. and in figurative contexts. Obs. Cf. regular adj. 7.

1650 T. Fuller Pisgah-sight of Palestine iv. iii. 45 Fight they durst not, being a multitude of undisciplin'd people, of all ages and sexes, against a regulated army of their enemies.
1690 London Gaz. No. 2568/3 We hear likewise that the French are in a great Allarm in Dauphine and Bresse, not having at present 1500 Men of regulated Troops on that side.
1714 J. Pointer Chronol. Hist. Eng. II. 461 The Muscovite Army was above 100000 Men, and the Swedes but 20000 Regulated Troops.
1769 J. Brown Dict. Holy Bible II. 487/1 What regulated troops of vigilant, active, and courageous ministers, armed with the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God.
1816 J. Aikin Ann. Reign of George III II. 253 On November 15, the Janissaries, who had massacred the principal officers of the regulated troops, scaled the walls of the seraglio.
I have been saying this forever. As I equally have been saying how INSANE it is we have randys1 Oct 2015 #1
There is a proposal in Illinois to automatically register anyone who signs up for a Driver's guillaumeb Oct 2015 #3
California just did that I think. randys1 Oct 2015 #4
Off topic but on target. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #5
Election fraud, is what cons do, and they do it in every single election they have a candidate. OT randys1 Oct 2015 #6
Also from the article: guillaumeb Oct 2015 #2
Yet the founding fathers, as Englishmen, enjoyed an individual right to bear arms hack89 Oct 2015 #7
The article is by Cass Sunstein. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #8
The Bill of Rights is a list of individual rights. Period. End of conversation. hack89 Oct 2015 #9
There are no unlimited rights. Even in the Heller decision, the SCOTUS guillaumeb Oct 2015 #13
Never said the 2A was unlimited. Nt hack89 Oct 2015 #23
Indeed. There are no communal or states' rights, only individual rights. Eleanors38 Oct 2015 #26
In my opinion, the problem with the misinterpretation is because people don't understand the Ghost in the Machine Oct 2015 #12
Care to fill us in more on "centuries of precedent"? dairydog91 Oct 2015 #10
cherry picking is an NRA specialty, especially when they make claims about how guns make guillaumeb Oct 2015 #14
Changing the language to "uniform understanding" doesn't seem relevant. dairydog91 Oct 2015 #18
Umm, Heller was not spearheaded by the NRA; in fact, they dragged along later... Eleanors38 Oct 2015 #27
The lawyer behind the Heller suit... PoliticAverse Oct 2015 #53
Let me help you with this.. virginia mountainman Oct 2015 #11
Nice picture. I wish I knew how to include pictures in my posts. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #15
it meant well functioning gejohnston Oct 2015 #16
Do yuo have anything to back up your interpretation of well regulated guillaumeb Oct 2015 #17
which has nothing to do with the US gejohnston Oct 2015 #20
More help... virginia mountainman Oct 2015 #22
breakfast amendment FAIL jimmy the one Oct 2015 #29
See Rose's "American Rifle: A Biography" for primary documentation... Eleanors38 Oct 2015 #28
To you, all all here who insist that all US residents are part of this "well regulated militia" guillaumeb Oct 2015 #30
To both your questions: No. Eleanors38 Oct 2015 #41
Why, yes, I do... tortoise1956 Oct 2015 #62
You might wish to look at Article 8 of the US Constitution, especially the clauses relating to a guillaumeb Oct 2015 #65
Section 8, actually... tortoise1956 Oct 2015 #67
And the Militia Acts of 1792, jmg257 Oct 2015 #73
Hamilton did...in Federalist #29 jmg257 Oct 2015 #72
And also consider this -- well-reguluated as an adj modifies militia and not the people. aikoaiko Nov 2015 #103
Your citations are interesting, but the Second Amendment and guillaumeb Nov 2015 #104
And Heller is now being used as a way to limit the right jmg257 Nov 2015 #106
The "law of unintended consequences"? eom guillaumeb Nov 2015 #108
Or "be careful what you wish for"! nt jmg257 Nov 2015 #113
Adding pictures is pretty easy. GGJohn Oct 2015 #21
Thanks. I did not realize that cut and paste worked in this context. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #31
Glad to be of help. GGJohn Oct 2015 #34
What part of "well regulated" don't YOU understand? Lurks Often Oct 2015 #25
An excellent question always deserves an excellent answer. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #32
How very nice of you to duck the "well regulated" part Lurks Often Oct 2015 #33
And I find no merit in the NRA view. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #35
I am struck by your repeated use of NRA "view" & "talking point." They aren't the only... Eleanors38 Oct 2015 #43
your views, and my views, represent our personal opinions. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #46
President Obama & the Democratic Party have stated the 2nd Amendment is an individual right Lurks Often Oct 2015 #51
Plenty of conservatives want to reduce or eliminate a civil liberty or two aikoaiko Oct 2015 #19
I find it hard to believe individuals didn't own guns until 2008. ileus Oct 2015 #24
I find this statement to be either uninformed or deliberately obtuse. Or possibly sarcasm? guillaumeb Oct 2015 #36
Well, it didn't take long to be expressed. Eleanors38 Oct 2015 #44
alan dershowitz pro militia jimmy the one Oct 2015 #37
alan dershowitz pro torture friendly_iconoclast Oct 2015 #39
A very nice response, but rather than the word miscomception I prefer guillaumeb Oct 2015 #47
militia centric jimmy the one Oct 2015 #52
I grounded my argument in the militia view because it corresponds to the Constitution and guillaumeb Oct 2015 #54
Sad thing is some folks buy into this BS. ileus Oct 2015 #38
...and demand the rest of us agree with them friendly_iconoclast Oct 2015 #40
2ndA was NOT an english individual rkba jimmy the one Oct 2015 #42
Exactly. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #48
you want stars & bars back too? jimmy the one Oct 2015 #45
Another great response. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #49
get a load of lurkso's source jimmy the one Oct 2015 #50
Remember when William Clinton attempted to defend his lies guillaumeb Oct 2015 #56
well regulated AND disciplined jimmy the one Oct 2015 #60
From the Constitution: guillaumeb Oct 2015 #61
individual rkba a corollary to militia clause jimmy the one Oct 2015 #55
There is even more to consider: guillaumeb Oct 2015 #57
You didn't mention the recreation of "the Militias of the Several States", jmg257 Oct 2015 #82
A very interresting point. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #84
Correct! A large standing Army-the very thing the militia clauses and the 2nd was trying to prevent! jmg257 Oct 2015 #86
I believe William Rawle... tortoise1956 Oct 2015 #63
Be prepared for a snarky remark from JTO, GGJohn Oct 2015 #64
Any chance you'd like to visit a casino? beevul Oct 2015 #69
LOL. GGJohn Oct 2015 #70
Rawle, Story, Oliver on 2ndA jimmy the one Oct 2015 #66
Interesting reply tortoise1956 Oct 2015 #68
not a lone voice, but irkba has 'no voice' jimmy the one Oct 2015 #71
Not the case tortoise1956 Oct 2015 #74
story rawle & tucker were militia believers jimmy the one Nov 2015 #90
Actually, I'm quoting Justice Stevens about the individual right tortoise1956 Nov 2015 #92
Consider that according to... discntnt_irny_srcsm Nov 2015 #93
I agree, but tortoise1956 Nov 2015 #94
It is plain from the various Militia Acts from 1792 to 1903... discntnt_irny_srcsm Nov 2015 #95
Yes - but times change, as do the laws, and notions of what is necessary... jmg257 Nov 2015 #96
Numerous times the usage "well regulated" has been discussed... discntnt_irny_srcsm Nov 2015 #97
heller dissent on 2ndA did not claim individual rkba jimmy the one Nov 2015 #98
Ahem. "Surely it protects a right that can be enforced by individuals." friendly_iconoclast Nov 2015 #99
iconic flop jimmy the one Nov 2015 #100
This is the last time I engage you, since you can't be bothered to actually fact-check yourself tortoise1956 Nov 2015 #114
tortoises are slow jimmy the one Nov 2015 #115
I spoke too soon tortoise1956 Nov 2015 #116
good rid jimmy the one Nov 2015 #117
tucker & english game laws 1671 jimmy the one Nov 2015 #91
you're wrong jimmy the one Oct 2015 #58
Excellent points about Heller. guillaumeb Oct 2015 #59
No police force? Straw Man Oct 2015 #75
What I SHOULD have written, guillaumeb Oct 2015 #76
Clarification received ... Straw Man Oct 2015 #77
Perhaps more of a "perceived need" for personal self defense? guillaumeb Oct 2015 #78
actually, the total homicide rate is gejohnston Oct 2015 #79
Nevertheless. Straw Man Oct 2015 #80
My comment was on the big difference between actual and perceived need. eom guillaumeb Oct 2015 #81
Difference based on misinterpretation of stats. nt Straw Man Oct 2015 #83
Will you provide clarification? guillaumeb Oct 2015 #85
Clarification. Straw Man Oct 2015 #87
True. Homicide does not directly equate but any time that a homicide takes place, guillaumeb Oct 2015 #88
Right. Straw Man Oct 2015 #89
Thanks for posting. patsimp Nov 2015 #101
My pleasure. I posted in response to all the fantasy history here. guillaumeb Nov 2015 #105
Fd riversedge Nov 2015 #102
The 'gun lobby' didn't rewrite anything. beevul Nov 2015 #107
You reply ignores the plain language of the Second Amendment, guillaumeb Nov 2015 #109
On the contrary. beevul Nov 2015 #110
Article 1, Section 8, US Constitution: guillaumeb Nov 2015 #111
Nonsense. beevul Nov 2015 #112
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»This message was self-del...»Reply #103