Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

discntnt_irny_srcsm

(18,567 posts)
13. In reply
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 07:26 PM
Jun 2016
"All guns should be confiscated." That won't happen nor is it feasible.

"theres endless examples of laws and rights changing" Laws change all the time whenever the legislature votes. Rights change? You have an alien definition of rights.

"_____ should be regulated by society to protect society." Perhaps society can be protected and even enhanced by having those on welfare subjected to involuntary kidney donation. Perhaps eugenics is good idea and the government should chose who can and can't have children. Maybe the government should choose your spouse for you. Perhaps you should rethink where the line should be drawn and exactly why.


In general, I think the US and its people have made it amply clear that they are not Europeans nor do wish to be. The minority that do have moved. I applaud certain aspects of areas that benefit from the government running and regulating much of the activity.


FYI, the Bill of Rights is incorporated into the Constitution as amendments. If you study US law, it becomes apparent that the rights referenced there are inviolate apart from due process. There have been from time to time laws counter to certain of those named rights and these laws have been or will be corrected. Sam Adams called it "the animating contest for freedom".


Another point, the US does not operate under what is known as parliamentary supremacy. The vote of a legislature is subject to the judgement of the courts. The people have the right to challenge a law.
Questions on gun-control/rights [View all] discntnt_irny_srcsm Jun 2016 OP
... Kang Colby Jun 2016 #1
I mostly agree discntnt_irny_srcsm Jun 2016 #12
Basically EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #2
In the process sarisataka Jun 2016 #3
So EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #4
I never mentioned the 18th sarisataka Jun 2016 #6
Agreed EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #7
IMO a program sarisataka Jun 2016 #8
We know that's not the case EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #9
So rather than sarisataka Jun 2016 #10
let's be clear EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #11
You say you want to do both sarisataka Jun 2016 #22
Yes and no EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #23
You are not open to everything sarisataka Jun 2016 #29
Nonsense EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #30
Why do you try and sarisataka Jun 2016 #31
Wait wait EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #32
I do not advocate sarisataka Jun 2016 #34
Lol EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #35
Glad to bring sarisataka Jun 2016 #37
Europe has much more democracy gejohnston Jun 2016 #15
No EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #17
nonsense gejohnston Jun 2016 #18
The state's role EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #19
some of the high schools gejohnston Jun 2016 #20
The states role is not to infringe. beevul Jun 2016 #40
Like I keep saying EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #43
And you keep being wrong. beevul Jun 2016 #51
define "highly trained" gejohnston Jun 2016 #5
In reply discntnt_irny_srcsm Jun 2016 #13
ok EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #14
Let's get this straight discntnt_irny_srcsm Jun 2016 #16
No EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #25
Laws regarding rights have changed discntnt_irny_srcsm Jun 2016 #38
Rights EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #39
You do not understand the fundamentals of American society. beevul Jun 2016 #44
No EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #45
No. Its YOU who are confused. beevul Jun 2016 #46
let me ask you this EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #47
Let me answer you this... beevul Jun 2016 #48
gun nuts ARE the problem EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #49
In your warped view. beevul Jun 2016 #50
On your statement about Jefferson: I think you've been somewhat misled about him. Decoy of Fenris Jun 2016 #36
Let me ask you a question... Puha Ekapi Jun 2016 #21
I have no real thoughts EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #24
Federally recognized tribes... Puha Ekapi Jun 2016 #26
again EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #27
And there lies the problem... Puha Ekapi Jun 2016 #55
"government interference" = CONTROL discntnt_irny_srcsm Jun 2016 #58
Knowing what has been done then, would you advocate complete confiscation... Marengo Jun 2016 #28
What about when society decides that the best plan safety plan is to keep the 2A as is? ileus Jun 2016 #41
Sure EdwardBernays Jun 2016 #42
Bravo. beardown Jun 2016 #33
51 replies...I can see all of one. Lizzie Poppet Jun 2016 #52
Camp Weathervane... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jun 2016 #53
Hillary backers. Lizzie Poppet Jun 2016 #54
Thanks discntnt_irny_srcsm Jun 2016 #57
^^ I've made the same observation. Interesting. NT pablo_marmol Jun 2016 #56
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»Questions on gun-control/...»Reply #13