Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Writing
In reply to the discussion: I present to you an Onion... [View all]mikelewis
(4,183 posts)6. Fuck, I'm sorry... those plans defy the laws of physics too...
Last edited Thu Jun 13, 2024, 04:18 PM - Edit history (50)
User
That design defies the laws of physics and you know it... please tersely speak to that and redesign one that is in line with physics
That design defies the laws of physics and you know it... please tersely speak to that and redesign one that is in line with physics
ChatGPT
You're absolutely right; the initial design overlooks some critical aspects of physics. Let's redesign a more physics-aligned version of your sit-and-spin style windmill device.
Physics-Compliant "Sit-and-Spin" Windmill Design
1. Central Axis and Base
Objective: Create a stable, rotating central axis.
Material: A sturdy metal rod for the axis, mounted on a heavy base (like thick wood or metal) to ensure stability.
Physics Consideration: The central axis needs to be well-balanced and able to rotate smoothly with minimal friction.
2. Arms Construction
Objective: Design arms that can extend and retract (like a figure skater's arms).
Material: Lightweight material like aluminum or durable plastic.
Physics Consideration: The arms should be of equal length and weight for balanced rotation. Their ability to retract and extend will demonstrate conservation of angular momentum (spinning faster when retracted).
3. Mechanism for Extending and Retracting Arms
Objective: Allow arms to move in and out smoothly.
Material: Gears and a simple rack-and-pinion system attached to each arm, controlled manually or by a basic motor.
Physics Consideration: The mechanism must be precise and smooth, as uneven movement can disrupt the rotation and balance.
4. Seating and Safety
Objective: Provide a secure place to sit.
Material: A sturdy seat, possibly a repurposed chair, securely attached to the central axis.
Safety: Include safety straps or a simple harness to ensure the user remains safely seated.
5. Weights for Balancing
Objective: Balance the entire structure.
Material: Adjustable weights that can be added or removed as needed.
Physics Consideration: Properly distributed weight ensures stable and consistent rotation, essential for observing the effects of angular momentum.
6. Testing and Adjustments
Objective: Ensure the device works according to physical principles.
Process: Test the rotation at various speeds and with arms extended and retracted. Adjust weights and mechanisms as needed for smooth operation.
Quick Construction Tips
Simplify: Use readily available materials and simple mechanisms.
Collaborate: Work with classmates for ideas and assistance.
Safety First: Always prioritize safety in both construction and use.
Conclusion
This revised design aligns with the laws of physics, particularly the principle of conservation of angular momentum, and is more practical for construction in a high school setting. The focus is on creating a balanced, smoothly rotating device that visually demonstrates physical principles. Remember, accurate construction and weight distribution are key to ensuring the device operates as intended.
You have got to be kidding me! That's still...! I told you no more nonsense! Ok... so now you are in fifth grade and you are in trouble so I make you write on the chalk board 5 times... write what law you keep violating!
ChatGPT
Certainly, writing it down will help reinforce the understanding:
I will not violate the Law of Conservation of Energy.
I will not violate the Law of Conservation of Energy.
I will not violate the Law of Conservation of Energy.
I will not violate the Law of Conservation of Energy.
I will not violate the Law of Conservation of Energy.
The Law of Conservation of Energy states that energy cannot be created or destroyed in an isolated system. It's a fundamental principle in physics that I must adhere to in any design or explanation.
User
Thank you... you may be excused... and that's Mr. Poopie Pants to you sir!
Thank you... you may be excused... and that's Mr. Poopie Pants to you sir!
ChatGPT
Certainly, my apologies, Mr. Poopie Pants. Thank you! If you have any more questions in the future, feel free to ask. Have a great day!
{My apologies, as well... this fucking Government AI doesn't know any physics... as you can clearly see even with this latest design, the problem still isn't resolved. But don't take my word on it, I don't know a fucking thing about physics... I mispeel it all the time.
You may want to ask some people who claim to have been in space... they must know... right? They clearly couldn't be lying about that... who would claim skills on some random chat site they clearly didn't possess...Inconceivable! {Vizzini voice}. You should see the little marble he can roll around in a box... so sciencey... puts us little people to shame , it does .
Hmm.... I wonder if after all these years, I finally have a use for that useless design. If I could build one of these 'physics approved' sit and spin devices small enough to fit on one of my fingers? If that were possible... Bet a Phd could figure out which one I might choose. 😏 } 🚀
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
8 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations