Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Religion
In reply to the discussion: What Does Water Represent In The Bible? A Christian Study [View all]guillaumeb
(42,649 posts)62. Flooding occurs everywhere. Even in that area of the world.
Do I interpret the flood story as being a literal inundation of the entire world?
No.
And as a non-literalist, that is no contradiction because we recognize the use of metaphor in the Bible.
Edited at 5.15 CST to add:
Most interpretations of the Biblical story of Noah and the Flood assume that the story is either entirely literal or entirely figurative (and therefore fictional). This assumption is unwarranted. Many Scripture passages contain both literal and figurative elements. For example, Jesus tells the disciples that Lazarus is sleeping He is using a figure. Then He explains that Lazarus is dead now He is speaking literally. Even the expression Love your neighbor contains both literal and figurative elements. The term love is literal. The term neighbor is a figure, meaning that we should treat even persons who are not our neighbors as if they were.
So we can hold that there was literally a Noah and a great Flood and an Ark with animals. But we can also hold that the story includes certain figurative elements: that the Flood covered all the earth, that the Ark contained all animals, that all humans were killed other than in the Ark, etc.
Any argument that proves the Flood could not have covered the whole earth, or that all human persons could not have been killed at that time, or that all animals could not have fit on the Ark, only proves that those elements are figurative. It does prove that the entire story is fiction.
So we can hold that there was literally a Noah and a great Flood and an Ark with animals. But we can also hold that the story includes certain figurative elements: that the Flood covered all the earth, that the Ark contained all animals, that all humans were killed other than in the Ark, etc.
Any argument that proves the Flood could not have covered the whole earth, or that all human persons could not have been killed at that time, or that all animals could not have fit on the Ark, only proves that those elements are figurative. It does prove that the entire story is fiction.
https://ronconte.wordpress.com/2011/01/03/noah-and-the-flood-literal-or-figurative/
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
183 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
There may have been a 'literal' flood literally, but the interpretation may be that it should be
sprinkleeninow
Dec 2018
#46
I'll get back to you, I will. With a reasoned answer and not one from my exegesis.
sprinkleeninow
Dec 2018
#23
Gil has posted no less than 4 links as a proof of concept for his "metaphor"
Major Nikon
Dec 2018
#16
It's cute how you've embraced your new tool to try and silence people who disagree with you.
trotsky
Dec 2018
#113
Here's yours: Liberal, Democrat, A sister or brother in humanity, a side-kick traveler
sprinkleeninow
Dec 2018
#107
I stand corrected. I AM delusional, but not in the way you have defined me.
sprinkleeninow
Dec 2018
#157
Well you defined this thread as a Christian Study, so sure, whatever, knock yourself out.
marylandblue
Dec 2018
#21
It's not a frackin' PRIVILEGE. It's something that was presented to me at forty days
sprinkleeninow
Dec 2018
#99
Hold the wire. I gotta be alert for the a.m. Lawn people are coming to dig a hole.
sprinkleeninow
Dec 2018
#93
The label of being afflicted with delusion regarding 'religion', all things God and Scripture, annnd
sprinkleeninow
Dec 2018
#173
"Water ... was used to literally cleanse the earth away from all that was evil and unholy"
muriel_volestrangler
Dec 2018
#177
"Here is a book written by arid-desert dwellers! What could water possibly have meant to them?
struggle4progress
Dec 2018
#179