Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Religion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

Duncanpup

(13,803 posts)
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 06:30 AM Nov 28

What are your thoughts in reading the Apocrypha [View all]

I’m asking those who believe what do you think so far I’ve read.
The book of Mary
Enoch
Wisdom of Solomon
And now The Gospel of Thomas and in reading Thomas i think i understand why it was excluded. In that it teaches we’re it is already inside of us.

And there is no need for organized church in our quest alls we need to do is look within ourselves and will find what we are looking for.

This is not assault on the early church or believers i was raised in church. Yet I have questions especially growing older i often think am i superstitious from being exposed as child to Christianity in that you have to believe because of the afterlife.

One question why were these books excluded did the early church know of them or did they not align with the early churches views and tossed aside.
The early church had two options either exalt women or oppress them and they chose option two.

I have been told by a pastor that the Apocrypha were not deemed legitimate then i ask why in asking him the book of Mary teaches us once again that salvation comes from within us no church no offering plate no middleman.

His reply was the same answer you have to have faith it’s ok to ask and have questions yet you must not stray to far I’m like huh.


And this pastor is a friend and he goes on that our God is a loving kind God.
I’m like huh God is a Narcissistic tyrant example if you do not love me then you will burn in eternity what kind of father would do that to his children.

And is eternal damnation another construct of early church to control us. And In early Hebrew when you’re dead that’s it nothing no afterlife if I’m correct in understanding what I have read both good and bad your gone and your children live on.

I have motivation in that if there is afterlife then i want in because I am in no rush to get there yet i want to see my wife again.

And in now looking to go to new church I'm thinking after reading do we need to attend church I was thinking of going to Unitarian church a friend of mine who truly does have compassion empathy love for others is quite the example and I’m impressed with her in knowing her these last two years.

A dyslexic bad punctuation ramble over coffee yet once again in closing as all of us i have questions yet no answers.

28 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
So fascinating. I hope you get some responses. Mike 03 Nov 28 #1
"...salvation comes from within us..." BoRaGard Nov 28 #2
A very timely question for me as I just got myself a copy EverHopeful Nov 28 #3
There is a reason enigmania Nov 28 #4
Yep PJMcK Nov 28 #6
Have you read the Gnostic texts? PJMcK Nov 28 #5
Yes I've read book of Mary Magdalene Duncanpup Nov 28 #7
To answer your question PJMcK Nov 28 #8
And to think if they would not have tried to keep us ignorant. Duncanpup Nov 28 #9
Humanity lost almost a thousand years of advancement PJMcK Nov 28 #22
Keep those cards and letters comming in WmChris Nov 28 #21
One of my favorites BlueMTexpat Nov 28 #10
judith is canon for catholics rampartd Nov 28 #11
King James Version PJMcK Nov 28 #23
the poetic language, even the "thees and thous" are what distinguish king james rampartd Nov 28 #24
People made decisions for hegemony... JT45242 Nov 28 #12
God is a loving God and there is no death. You will see your wife again, Dunc judesedit Nov 28 #13
I'm firmly in the St Thomas camp. 🙂 MLAA Nov 28 #14
Life Long Student Bible Nag Hamadi, Apocrypha, Vedanta & Yogananda OhNo-Really Nov 28 #15
Thank you very much for that. judesedit Nov 28 #27
You're welcome ✨ OhNo-Really Nov 29 #28
I think that you are on the Right Track. beemerphill Nov 28 #16
There never was one christanity, as studies of the earliest writings show. What Karadeniz Nov 28 #17
It seems as I'm as familiar with Apocrypha as GOP politicians are with Matthew. surfered Nov 28 #18
We left our lifelong church in 2010 but exmodee Nov 28 #19
Religion? WmChris Nov 28 #20
Revelation is unnecesary Fichefinder Nov 28 #25
Modern Christianity owes its entire structure to late Roman Imperial politics localroger Nov 28 #26
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»What are your thoughts in...»Reply #0