Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Gun Control Reform Activism
In reply to the discussion: NYC bill would put NYPD gun offender database online [View all]I can see two major problems with your idea.
1) Having such a list would allow criminals to target the homes of gun owners and lead to the theft of their firearms while their homes were unoccupied. (Even if a gun owner stored his weapons in a very expensive safe, an experienced thief can break into the safe giving enough time).
Choosing a Gun Safe
***snip***
When looking at the different thickness of steel in the chart above, you may be tempted to think that the differences are so small that there couldnt possibly be much difference between a 12 gauge safe and a 10 gauge safe, its only 1/32 of an inch difference, most rulers dont even show hash marks that small. Yet consider that two safes with identical dimensions from the same manufacturer, one in 12 gauge and the other in 10 gauge, weigh 595 lbs. and 882 lbs. respectively. The point here is that a little bit of extra steel adds a lot of extra weight and strength.
Real security from an actual attack, rather than simply keeping the curiously innocent out, begins at 11 gauge, which is 1/8th of an inch thick. This is the thickness at which you begin to see safes with a UL RSC (Underwriters Laboratories Residential Security Container) certification. With an RSC label, youll know that the UL has certified the safe to withstand at least 5 minutes of attack with common tools such as pry bars, hammers, and axes. You might be thinking that 5 minutes isnt very long, but keep in mind that is the minimum amount of time the safe had to withstand attack, many safes take much longer to get into and require a lot of noise to do so. When you consider that most home robberies are smash and grab type where the thieves want to get in and out quickly, spending more than five minutes making a lot of noise trying to bust open a safe will discourage most thieves.
There is no such thing as an impenetrable safe. Given enough time and the proper tools any safe can be opened. What you are buying when you spend more money on a heavier safe is more steel and that translates directly into more time required to break in. Your added investment is putting extra minutes between your valuables and the thieves who are trying to get to them. When deciding how thick the steel in your safe needs to be, consider factors such as where you live. Are you in a rural or urban area? Do you have alert neighbors nearby, or is your home in an area where a thief could spend hours making noise virtually unnoticed? What other layers do you have in your home protection plan, such as an alarm system or dogs who will bark at strangers? Is your home occupied throughout most of the day and night, or empty most of the time? In an urban area with neighbors close by and a fast response time from police, 11 gauge will serve you very well and 10 gauge is even better. In a more rural setting where a thief could spend significant time unnoticed in your home (and in a rural setting you are more likely to have heavier tools on hand which can assist the thief) you should consider a heavier safe, 7 gauge minimum, or even ¼ inch or thicker.
[1]emphasis added
https://www.gunup.com/advice/choosing-gun-safe
2) Such a list would enable a criminal to find homes of non gun owners and invade them with impunity (especially if he was armed with a gun he had stolen from a gun owners home). You and your family could find yourselves victims of a home invasion.
Often what seems to be a great idea has unintended consequences.
The criminal element is largely responsible for gun violence in our nation. They often obtain their weapons by either stealing them or buying stolen weapons on the street. Of course another means is by buying a weapon that has been bought by a straw purchaser for the criminal or bought and then smuggled into the city for illegal sale.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
20 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Your fears seem based on the assumption criminals are currently stymied in their attempts
Robb
Aug 2013
#3
You must lose sleep thinking about that evil DMV and their database of car owners!
DanTex
Aug 2013
#10
I posted to state that as a NYC resident that I DID NOT OPPOSE the offender registry.
branford
Aug 2013
#15