Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Justice Alito singled out as roadblock to stalled Trump criminal immunity ruling [View all]Fiendish Thingy
(18,999 posts)57. Not at all, I have no doubt Alito is one of two likely pro-immunity votes on SCOTUS
And, IMO, delaying any trial until after the election was the primary motivation in SCOTUS accepting the immunity case, not the merits of the case itself. The delay in issuing the opinion until the end of the term was baked in the moment they accepted the case.
But, as with those who presume that Garland intentionally obstructed or delayed Trumps investigations, there is no evidence to support Sterns specific speculation about Alito and the rest of the court.
Speaking with the hosts, Stern was asked why the court is dragging its feet on a case that could have a major impact on the 2024 presidential election. "I think the problem here is that the Supreme Court's conservatives are, if not corrupt, then wrapped up in this fantasy of a presidency that has safeguards, that has guard rails against abuse and corruption and they don't think what Donald Trump did at the end of the day, was all that bad,(I believe Alito and Thomas may feel that way, but there is no evidence the entire conservative bloc does)" the legal analysts stated.
"This came out loud and clear in the conservatives' decision on the ballot removal case where the court refused to grapple with this question on whether Trump engaged in insurrection, refused to address the true gravity of January 6, and issued a very formalistic non-originalist opinion that allows Trump to appear on the ballot, despite the 14th's Amendment clear bar against insurrectionists holding federal office," he continued.(this is the part I consider the most nonsensical, as it ignores the liberals who concurred with the ruling, which had nothing to do with Trumps disqualification, it was about whether a state had the power to disqualify a candidate for federal office, and they correctly ruled it does not. The suit should have been filed in federal, not state, court.)
"This came out loud and clear in the conservatives' decision on the ballot removal case where the court refused to grapple with this question on whether Trump engaged in insurrection, refused to address the true gravity of January 6, and issued a very formalistic non-originalist opinion that allows Trump to appear on the ballot, despite the 14th's Amendment clear bar against insurrectionists holding federal office," he continued.(this is the part I consider the most nonsensical, as it ignores the liberals who concurred with the ruling, which had nothing to do with Trumps disqualification, it was about whether a state had the power to disqualify a candidate for federal office, and they correctly ruled it does not. The suit should have been filed in federal, not state, court.)
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
61 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Justice Alito singled out as roadblock to stalled Trump criminal immunity ruling [View all]
Tom of Temecula
Jun 2024
OP
Flood his mail box with post cards with one word in big black sharpie on it .....
Hotler
Jun 2024
#1
I always thought Scalia was the worst supreme Court Justice in my lifetime but..
yourout
Jun 2024
#2
RBG was friends with him, despite a chasm of ideological divide. I doubt she ever was with the corrupt Alito and Thomas.
Celerity
Jun 2024
#59
I still wanna know what Trump said to Justice Kennedy that day they were walking away and he stopped short
Walleye
Jun 2024
#38
Very speculative. The ruling will come eventually and nobody really knows anything that's happening behind the scenes.
ColinC
Jun 2024
#28
There was a real hard deadline in the Colorado case. The date for the primary had been set.
onenote
Jun 2024
#56
So, as you were with Garland, you are convinced that the right thing is going on behind the scenes?
Scrivener7
Jun 2024
#48
Not at all, I have no doubt Alito is one of two likely pro-immunity votes on SCOTUS
Fiendish Thingy
Jun 2024
#57
Trump is promising he will do it again. And I guess they are confident in their safety because
Walleye
Jun 2024
#9
I think the upside down "Stop the Steal" flag tells us exactly what Alito and his wife support.
Lonestarblue
Jun 2024
#19
Roberts needs to get his act together. He can't let Thomas and Alito derail the court very time they
Martin68
Jun 2024
#11
Yet, the Supreme Court has ruled against trump on just about every election and aftermath case. It will
Silent Type
Jun 2024
#17
"The delay is in trump's favor" Yes. Yes it is. And there's absolutely no other reason for it.
Scrivener7
Jun 2024
#49
This is a major part of the Project '25 agenda. The rethugs have been working toward this since Reagan.
Texin
Jun 2024
#18
I've been asking the same questions since An Inconvenient Truth dropped back in the late '90s.
Texin
Jun 2024
#43
Justice Alito singled out as roadblock to stalled Trump criminal immunity ruling
LetMyPeopleVote
Jun 2024
#29