Latest Breaking News

OKIsItJustMe

(21,016 posts)

33. It doesn't need to have been declared an insurrection. Nor does he even have to have taken par in it.

Reply to Polybius (Reply #31)

Fri Nov 29, 2024, 03:44 PM

Nov 29

… shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same, or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof. …

https://openyls.law.yale.edu/bitstream/handle/20.500.13051/11345/27_27YaleLJ331_1917_1918_.pdf?sequence=2&isAllowed=y

WHAT IS GIVING AID AND COMFORT
TO THE ENEMY?
CHARLES WARREN
Washington, D. C.

…

In Young v. United States it was held that the words "aid or comfort to the rebellion" as used in the Captured and Abandoned Property Act of March 12, 1863, in the Civil War, were used in the same sense as in the Constitution defining treason--"that is to say, in their hostile sense"; and in that case, where a man contracted with the government of the State of North Carolina to provide warlike supplies and to aid in running cotton out through the blockade, and performed acts carrying out his contract, it was held that the acts were clearly treasonable.

…

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

36 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Bannon changes tune on Musk, says he's 'impressed' [View all] OKIsItJustMe Nov 28 OP

But Bannon himself is a POS. Sneederbunk Nov 28 #1

I wish DU would ban anything of bannon, he's a felon, who ripped off people, went to jail, and did his time, and will go SWBTATTReg Nov 28 #2

Ignorance of what people like Bannon are up to is not helpful OKIsItJustMe Nov 28 #3

I understand but it's helpful to know even Bannon thinks he moved the race greatly, mahina Nov 28 #4

I mean, Trump is also a felon, and it would be completely impossible to ban all mention of him. Especially now. Karasu Nov 29 #22

$$$ speak easy Nov 28 #5

There is no such thing as the department of government efficiency. Ms. Toad Nov 28 #6

Yep TimeToGo Nov 28 #7

Yep TimeToGo Nov 28 #8

Department of Government Efficiency (DoGE) OKIsItJustMe Nov 28 #9

My point is that media needs to call them on it Ms. Toad Nov 28 #10

Oh! You must be a member of the "Reality-based community!" - How sweet! OKIsItJustMe Nov 28 #12

boy, wouldn't it be great if congress bothered taking a vote on this. they won't...but it would be great if they did. nt orleans Nov 29 #16

And, if the 14th can simply be ignored, why not the 22nd as well? OKIsItJustMe Nov 29 #17

I'm very, very much afraid that's where we're heading. Karasu Nov 29 #21

That's a lot clearer n/t Polybius Nov 29 #29

That's if Congress first convicts him of insurrection Polybius Nov 29 #28

No, that's not necessary OKIsItJustMe Nov 29 #30

"The Court noted, however, that states retain concurrent authority to enforce Section 3 with respect to state offices" Polybius Nov 29 #31

It doesn't need to have been declared an insurrection. Nor does he even have to have taken par in it. OKIsItJustMe Nov 29 #33

Someone has to determine it an insurrection Polybius Nov 29 #34

Apropos of very little OKIsItJustMe Nov 28 #14

Bannon needs to go the fuck away lonely bird Nov 28 #11

Nobody is getting stripped of citizenship. jimfields33 Nov 29 #26

Well, there's a ringing endorsement. LisaM Nov 28 #13

But that would encompass the entire administration. Karasu Nov 29 #19

Washed-up fascist kisses newer, more popular fascist's ass. News at 11. Karasu Nov 29 #15

Who gives a fuck? NEOBuckeye Nov 29 #18

Underestimate your opponents at your peril OKIsItJustMe Nov 29 #20

Oh believe me, I'm not. NEOBuckeye Nov 29 #23

Good question RandiFan1290 Nov 30 #36

This message was self-deleted by its author moniss Nov 29 #24

As if I give a shit. (nt) Paladin Nov 29 #25

"And look, we have huge ideological differences, including about the Chinese Communist Party" Polybius Nov 29 #27

This message was self-deleted by its author JudyM Nov 29 #32

Bannon...says he's 'impressed' LudwigPastorius Nov 30 #35