Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

wnylib

(24,507 posts)
12. I agree that studies of religion would
Mon Dec 21, 2020, 04:55 PM
Dec 2020

benefit people in understanding the cultural role of religions. But I can foresee problems that would come out of trying to do it.

Many atheists would complain that children were being taught religion and would miss the difference between being taught ABOUT religion and being taught to FOLLOW a religion. And, people of various religions and sects within religions would complain about children being exposed to other views.

In my public school, we learned about the Protestant Reformation since it had such a strong influence on European history. Growing up in a Protestant family, I had already learned about it. Our teacher was Catholic and taught it from a Catholic perspective, misrepresenting a few historical facts. Some teachers cannot maintain objectivity.

In my home state of PA, it was law that public school teachers start each day by reading a chapter from the King James Protestant Bible. Catholic students rightly objected. When SCOTUS struck down the law, the pastor of our church supported the ruling in his sermon by reminding people that it is the responsibility of parents and religious institutions, not schoolteachers, to teach their faith to their own children, in order to preserve religious liberty.

But, for some subjects, learning about a religion is necessary. When in college, I did some practice teaching sessions for middle school Spanish classes. It was spring, so my lesson plans included Spanish and Latin American customs regarding Easter. It is nearly impossible to teach Spanish without references to religion since it is so much a part of Spanish history, culture, and language. Numerous Spanish idioms are based on religious stories and customs. Some are Christian and some are Islamic. I was concerned that some parents might object, but the supervising teacher agreed with me on the need to explain the sources and history and said she would handle the parents.

On Buddhism, I had a very hyper, easily agitated supervisor once who started studying Buddhism when she dated a Buddhist. It's one of the few times that I saw a really visible, measurable change in a person as a result of religion.

Thou art but dust, and to dust you shall return Miguelito Loveless Feb 2020 #1
Protestant and Orthodox churches celebrate Ash Wednesday too, you know. shrike3 Sep 2020 #2
It started with the Roman church Miguelito Loveless Sep 2020 #4
If you are indeed an ex-Catholic, your comment demonstrates an astonishing ignorance shrike3 Sep 2020 #5
"If" Miguelito Loveless Sep 2020 #6
Hey, I don't know you. We all can be anyone we want on the Internets shrike3 Sep 2020 #7
So, you're default setting Miguelito Loveless Sep 2020 #8
I'm not a newbie. I've probably been on the site longer than you have. shrike3 Sep 2020 #9
Some think Ash Wednesday has its roots in the Jewish tradition of penance and fasting shrike3 Sep 2020 #3
I just came across this thread wnylib Dec 2020 #10
There's also a fasting tradition in buddhism shrike3 Dec 2020 #11
I agree that studies of religion would wnylib Dec 2020 #12
I am told religion is taught as an academic subject in Europe without any problems. shrike3 Dec 2020 #13
Sadly true about the culture wars. Zealots from all quarters, wnylib Dec 2020 #15
I'm glad to know someone else finds religion interesting, above and beyond the "faith" sense. It has shrike3 Dec 2020 #18
To the extent that Xtianity was used wnylib Dec 2020 #19
Thanks for your thoughts: very interesting. shrike3 Dec 2020 #20
On a personal level, I stay with wnylib Dec 2020 #21
Then again, I'm told the course is comparative religion, not any religion in particular. shrike3 Dec 2020 #14
Within Christianity, there are varying wnylib Dec 2020 #16
Sadly, you're right. Political power struggles with religion used as an excuse. shrike3 Dec 2020 #17
I had the best professor in college ('70's) for World Religions... electric_blue68 Dec 2021 #22
Wow. Sounds like a great experience. Lucky you. shrike3 Dec 2021 #23
Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Interfaith Group»so--I confess my ignoranc...»Reply #12